After much debate and political wrangling, a section of Oxford Street has been pedestrianised. Highways paid a visit to find out what people think of this potentially influential move. 

Sometimes called the nation's high street, Oxford Street in London has become synonymous with shopping, holiday lights, but more often than not, crowds. For those who make the visit, it is unlikely you would escape un-barged as you make your way among thousands down the cramped pavements. For those who live in the capital, it is generally avoided, barring some last-minute 'gift emergency'.

However, in the run-up to Christmas this year, things have changed. A near-1km stretch of the route between Orchard Street and Great Portland Street has now been pedestrianised - so only pedestrians and those using mobility aids are able to traverse the street (in theory – in practice, it is not uncommon to see the odd cyclist flout the ban ).

undefined
Road closed sign on Oxford Street

Speaking to some of the visitors to Oxford Street, some thought that the change was long overdue; in fact, Highways spoke to a gentleman who said it was ‘about time' that the street was closed to traffic, having been arrested in 1971 for ‘closing' the street in 1971 during a protest.

‘I was arrested probably around [where we are stood] and now, 51 years later, it's done,' he explained

Coincidentally, Highways met Jess Gallagher, lighting business development manager for Groupe RAGNI UK, who had ventured out to the street to see for herself what difference the changes had made.

When asked what she thought of the street now, she was very positive: ‘I think it's brilliant. I'm really keen on it. I think it's giving space to people instead of putting traffic at the heart of something, and I think it's going to make a big difference.'

She also said that she hadn't come across anyone cycling down the street.

‘Everybody seems to be complying,' she said, ‘pushing their bikes along. It's a lovely atmosphere as well.'

Several others thought that the change was a positive move, including some of those working in the shops. While they didn't want to be quoted by name, as they were at work, one employee said that she had noticed more people coming into the shops, as the increased space meant people were no longer forced to ‘beeline' from one place to another.

Thanks to this, she explained, people appeared to me more likely to take their time and stop in shops, as they felt more relaxed.

The change has not only received positive reactions, though.

A couple, who were regular visitors, had a more mixed reaction to the presentation of the scheme.

‘It's a good idea,' one said, ‘but it just looks such a mess. We've expected it to look a bit pedestrianised, rather than just bollards.

‘It feels very temporary. I think if they eventually do what they're planning to do where it is fully pedestrianised and make it look nice, then I think it would be better. It just feels a bit unfinished.

‘It needed doing, I do think it needed doing, just needs to look nicer.'

Highways also spoke to Lu, a cyclist who was walking his bike down the street, who felt that it was a shame that he and other cyclists had been banned along with motorists.

‘I think it's great that cars are gone,' he explained, ‘but I grew up in the Netherlands, I'm Dutch, so obviously I love cycling, and I think a marker of a civil, modern city is the amount of cyclists in it. Right now, there's no clear route [for cyclists], so you're basically just kind of going through all the alleyways, which is really impractical for cyclists.

‘I know that London's got a bit of a reputation for like phone theft and whatnot, so I do get that that may be the reason behind the cyclists being banned as well, but I think that's such a small minority among people like me who just want to get to where they need to go a bit faster than the route that we have to take now.'

undefined
Cyclist speaking to TfL Staff

It appeared that many other cyclists shared this sentiment, and despite Ms Gallagher's observations, not all were as willing to abide by the new regulations.

While at Oxford Street for just a few hours, Highways saw multiple cyclists ignoring the new barriers. Some were delivery riders, some rode shared rental bikes and others, as was the case in one instance, were young people seemingly enjoying the fact that they were breaking the rules. One group of teenagers on bikes even got in a yelling match with a woman who took objection to their presence and the danger that she felt they posed to her and her family.

While TfL staff on-site at the time were unable to comment, a spokesperson for TfL has since told Highways: ‘The number of cyclists who are using Oxford Street is significantly down compared to when the route was open to traffic. We continue to educate and inform those who attempt to cycle along the traffic-free section to advise them to walk their bike and take an alternative route, with more signage installed throughout the week and increased enforcement presence on the street to help further deter cyclists.

‘TfL recognises the need to provide high-quality alternative routes through the area and is engaging with Westminster City Council to support the development of these proposals. TfL has also updated its journey planner and TfL Go app to highlight alternative routes for cyclists.

 ‘As with any major change in road layout and rules, TfL's approach is to engage and educate first.  As more people become aware of the changes, and as more greenery and seating are installed within the traffic-free area, the number of incidents is expected to decrease. We will maintain an active presence of enforcement officers.'

They added that all cyclists, e-scooter users and pedicabs will be ‘physically banned' from entering pedestrianised sections on Oxford Street with the use of barriers, and said that there will be signs ‘asking people to walk their bikes in the traffic-free zone', along with a ‘heightened TfL enforcement officer presence'.

To tackle those using rented bicycles or e-bikes, TfL has put ‘strict geo-fencing' in place which will ‘automatically cut or reduce power for dockless e-bikes should they attempt to enter the traffic free area'. As well as this, TfL plans to ‘monitor and work with suppliers to remove any e-bikes found in the area'.

TfL stated that it will ‘continue to monitor and review the design of the scheme to ensure that there is adequate signage, specially designed physical measures and sufficient on-street enforcement'. It also plans to raise the road surface to the pavement level to create a single level surface in the pedestrianised areas yet to be started - the first two sections are scheduled to be completed in spring 2027. If the cyclist issue is not resolved, this may make the scheme even more controversial, as previously many 'shared space' projects have infamously run into trouble over accessibility issues for blind and partially sighted people.

It could be a while before we have a definitive answer on whether Oxford Street's pedestrianisation has been successful or not, but pedestrian charity Living Streets has already called for more cities to follow the example of Oxford Street.

One way or another, this scheme could be hugely influential when it comes to place-shaping and the modern highway street.