Amey set for another legal showdown

30/07/2018
Dominic Browne

Amey is set for another showdown with a major council after partially winning an early round in a legal battle with West Sussex County Council.

Amey Highways Ltd had asked for the High Court for a summary judgement in the case, after West Sussex awarded its Highways Term Service Contract 2018-2028 to Ringway. 

While a summary judgement was not granted, the council failed to have the case thrown out either on the grounds that Amey ran out of time to take legal action, or that Amey's case had no chance of success.

This has left the two parties set for further legal action if no resolution can be found. The news comes just months after lost another battle with Birmingham City Council.

The judgement states that Amey’s case 'may be subdivided into two broad categories of attack':

'i) Amey alleges that instructions given by the Council on 19 January and/or 2 February 2018 about how it should structure its presentation of certain staff costs were unlawful. It is not in dispute that implementation of the instructions had the effect of reducing the score that Amey’s tender would receive in respect of price. 

ii) Amey alleges manifest error in the scoring of two criteria and that it should have been awarded a higher score for those criteria.'

The way the tender and its costings was outlined, Justice Stuart-Smith states, meant local office overheads 'also fell to be included in either Total Revenue Costs or Total Capital Costs for any of years 1-7, the structure of the ITT’s [Invitation to Tender] costing model would mean that such costs were brought into the tenderer’s submitted pricing twice'.

'There was therefore an incentive for tenderers not to include sums appearing in their Total Costs in the LMO as well. On the documentary evidence it appears that Amey was conscious of the possibility that other tenderers might gain an unfair advantage by wrongly excluding costs from LMO that should have been included there'

Amey alleges it received instructions from the council relating to this situation - specifically relating to the equivalent of 4.25 full time employees that Amey asserted would not come at the council's expense - that were unlawful. Related to this, Amey alleges it should have scored higher on its scorecards.

Mr Justice Stuart-Smith ruled: 'I am not convinced that this is one of those relatively rare cases where the claim can be seen to be overwhelmingly strong or weak. I have not been addressed and am not in a position to make a reliable estimate of the strength or weakness of Amey’s claim or the Council’s proposed substantive defence save to say that neither appears to be fanciful on the materials and submissions that have been available and made at the present hearing.' 

Determination of the issues requires 'close consideration of the factual evidence that is beyond the scope of a strike out/summary judgement application', the ruling states. 

The procurement process was subject to a competitive dialogue process, involving three stages: first, an Invitation to Submit Outline Solutions; second, a Competitive Dialogue and; third, a Call for Final Tenders.

The Invitation to Tender divided the tender submission into two sections, quality and cost. The quality submission was worth 40% of the overall score with the cost submission being worth 60%.

Highways approached Amey and West Sussex County Council for comment.

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Also Inside:

  • Traffex Parkex review
  • Round table: Mastering modern contracting
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Highway Asset Principal (Performance & Information)

£44,624-£48,684
We're eager to find a compelling and persuasive individual to take advantage of this brand-new opportunity within our Highways Asset Team. Lancashire
Recruiter: Lancashire County Council

Inspector / Senior Inspector

£22,129 - £32,798 pa
Bradford Metropolitan District Council is seeking to recruit an Inspector/Senior Inspector to join the friendly Highway Maintenance Team Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of Bradford MDC

Assistant Contracts Manager

£29,184 to £32,389 - Plus market leading package (see below)
Derbyshire County Council are looking for an experienced Assistant Contract Manager Willington, Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

HGV Mechanic

£23,657 - £25,568 per annum – plus market leading package (see below)
We are looking for a highly motivated Heavy Goods Vehicle Mechanic to join our County Transport team. Brimington, Chesterfield
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Procurement Programme Manager

£54,873 – £60,366
We have an exciting opportunity for a Procurement Programme Manager to join our team. Stratford, London (Greater)
Recruiter: East London Waste Authority (ELWA)

Team Leader LGV Driver

£22,571 - £25,419
An opportunity exists in the Council’s Street Scene Services for a Team Leader LGV Driver. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Multi Skilled Operative

£20,444 - £22,129
We are seeking enthusiastic and capable colleagues to join our Highway Operations team. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Transportation Planner

£35,336 - £39,571
A Transportation Planner is required for the analysis and monitoring of traffic, to design and undertake feasibility studies. Pembroke, Pembrokeshire (Sir Benfro)
Recruiter: Pembrokeshire County Council

Senior Technician

£27,514
We are looking to recruit a Senior Technician within the busy Structures team. Pontypridd, Rhondda Cynon Taf
Recruiter: Rhondda Cynon Taff County Borough Council

Senior Engineer

£36,371
We are looking to recruit a Senior Engineer within the Structures team. Pontypridd, Rhondda Cynon Taf
Recruiter: Rhondda Cynon Taff County Borough Council

Highways Transport Strategy and Development Manager

£52,848 - £64,998
This is a unique opportunity to join a newly formed unitary authority which is mobilising a new highways contract. Northampton, Northamptonshire
Recruiter: West Northamptonshire Council

Assistant Engineer

£27,514 to £29,174 per annum
A great opportunity has arisen for an enthusiastic and self-motivated individual to join our team Preston, Lancashire
Recruiter: Preston City Council

Highways Network Manager

£52,848 - £64,998
We are forming a new highways and transport team for West Northamptonshire Council Northampton, Northamptonshire
Recruiter: West Northamptonshire Council

Highways Service Manager (Commissioning & Contract Management)

£52,848 - £64,998
We are now looking to recruit a number of talented, motivated and innovative individuals. Northampton, Northamptonshire
Recruiter: West Northamptonshire Council

Principal Officer (Network Coordination)

£39,571 - £42,614
We are looking for experienced and well-motivated staff to help shape the future delivery of the service. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recruiter: Oxfordshire County Council

Highways Development Manager

£44,624 per annum plus £3,000 Market Forces
We are actively recruiting for Highways Development Managers within the Environment & Transport Department Hertford, Hertfordshire
Recruiter: Hertfordshire County Council

Senior Highways Officer

£36,371 per annum plus £2,000 Market Forces
Hertfordshire truly is the County of Opportunity Hertford, Hertfordshire
Recruiter: Hertfordshire County Council

Senior Engineer (Highway Maintenance)

£33,486 - £42,614 per annum
Bradford Metropolitan District Council is seeking to recruit a Senior Engineer Keighley, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of Bradford MDC

Assistant Director Planning, Transportation and Highways

£88,896 - £100,749
We’re looking for a leader who can enable and unlock the potential of our teams, Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of Bradford MDC

Contracting Engineer

£33,513 - £37,588 pay award pending
We are passionate about Doncaster - it’s a great place to live, do business and visit. Doncaster, South Yorkshire
Recruiter: Doncaster Council

Highways Presents

 

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video