Amey set for another legal showdown

30/07/2018
Dominic Browne

Amey is set for another showdown with a major council after partially winning an early round in a legal battle with West Sussex County Council.

Amey Highways Ltd had asked for the High Court for a summary judgement in the case, after West Sussex awarded its Highways Term Service Contract 2018-2028 to Ringway. 

While a summary judgement was not granted, the council failed to have the case thrown out either on the grounds that Amey ran out of time to take legal action, or that Amey's case had no chance of success.

This has left the two parties set for further legal action if no resolution can be found. The news comes just months after lost another battle with Birmingham City Council.

The judgement states that Amey’s case 'may be subdivided into two broad categories of attack':

'i) Amey alleges that instructions given by the Council on 19 January and/or 2 February 2018 about how it should structure its presentation of certain staff costs were unlawful. It is not in dispute that implementation of the instructions had the effect of reducing the score that Amey’s tender would receive in respect of price. 

ii) Amey alleges manifest error in the scoring of two criteria and that it should have been awarded a higher score for those criteria.'

The way the tender and its costings was outlined, Justice Stuart-Smith states, meant local office overheads 'also fell to be included in either Total Revenue Costs or Total Capital Costs for any of years 1-7, the structure of the ITT’s [Invitation to Tender] costing model would mean that such costs were brought into the tenderer’s submitted pricing twice'.

'There was therefore an incentive for tenderers not to include sums appearing in their Total Costs in the LMO as well. On the documentary evidence it appears that Amey was conscious of the possibility that other tenderers might gain an unfair advantage by wrongly excluding costs from LMO that should have been included there'

Amey alleges it received instructions from the council relating to this situation - specifically relating to the equivalent of 4.25 full time employees that Amey asserted would not come at the council's expense - that were unlawful. Related to this, Amey alleges it should have scored higher on its scorecards.

Mr Justice Stuart-Smith ruled: 'I am not convinced that this is one of those relatively rare cases where the claim can be seen to be overwhelmingly strong or weak. I have not been addressed and am not in a position to make a reliable estimate of the strength or weakness of Amey’s claim or the Council’s proposed substantive defence save to say that neither appears to be fanciful on the materials and submissions that have been available and made at the present hearing.' 

Determination of the issues requires 'close consideration of the factual evidence that is beyond the scope of a strike out/summary judgement application', the ruling states. 

The procurement process was subject to a competitive dialogue process, involving three stages: first, an Invitation to Submit Outline Solutions; second, a Competitive Dialogue and; third, a Call for Final Tenders.

The Invitation to Tender divided the tender submission into two sections, quality and cost. The quality submission was worth 40% of the overall score with the cost submission being worth 60%.

Highways approached Amey and West Sussex County Council for comment.

Highways jobs

Senior Transport Officer

St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council
£31,401 to £34,106 per annum
St Helens Council is seeking an exceptional Transport Planner to fulfil a role supporting our growth agenda St Helens, Merseyside
Recuriter: St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council

TRANSPORT FOR WALES APPOINTMENT OF NON-EXECUTIVE CHAIR

Transport for Wales
£425.00 per day
Transport for Wales (TfW) is a not for profit company, wholly-owned by the Welsh Government and established in 2015. Wales
Recuriter: Transport for Wales

Executive Director - Place

Lincolnshire County Council
Up to £130,000
Fantastic opportunities to join our team to help us shape the delivery of services across Lincolnshire. Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Transport and Depot Manager

New Forest District Council
Circa £45,000
New Forest District Council are looking to recruit a Transport and Depot Manager who will be the lead officer on fleet maintenance Marsh Lane Depot, Lymington
Recuriter: New Forest District Council

Pest Control Officer

Brent Council
£25,746 - £27,342 p.a. inc.
Salary range
Recuriter: Brent Council

StreetCare Supervisor (Highways)

South Gloucestershire Council
£28,221 - £30,756
The post holder shall be responsible for supervising the implementation of civil and structural engineering schemes Gloucestershire
Recuriter: South Gloucestershire Council

Senior Manager Roads (Structure, Lighting, Flooding & Design)

North Ayrshire Council
£52,818.84 - £56,034.29 per year
You will be involved in leading a professional Team of employees responsible for the management of all Roads Structures Irvine, North Ayrshire
Recuriter: North Ayrshire Council

Engineering Manager (Structures, Street Lighting and Signals)

Plymouth City Council
£42 806 - £47,546
We are looking for a dynamic Engineering Manager Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Highways Maintenance Manager

Plymouth City Council
£37,107 - £41,846
We are looking for a dynamic Highways Manager Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Highways Asset Manager

Plymouth City Council
£32,333 - £36,153
We are looking for a dynamic Highways Asset Manager to lead and co-ordinate our new Highways Asset Management team Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Engineer - Capital Projects

Liverpool City Council
£32,233 - £37,107
Liverpool City Council is looking to recruit an Engineer - Capital Projects. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Asset Management Officer (inc Signals)

Liverpool City Council
£27,358 - £31,401
Liverpool City Council wish to recruit an Asset Management Officer to assist with the delivery of highway maintenance... Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Technical Assistant

Liverpool City Council
£23,111 - £27,358
Liverpool City Council are looking to recruit a Technical Assistant. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Divisional Manager - Major Projects

Liverpool City Council
£65,013 - £69,812
Liverpool City Council wish to recruit a Divisional Manager - Major Projects to act as the strategic lead Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Team Leader - Asset Management

Liverpool City Council
£41,846 - £46,560
Liverpool City Council wish to recruit a Team Leader to be responsible for the development and management of the highways Asset Management Team Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Site Supervisor

Liverpool City Council
£32,233 - £37,107
Liverpool City Council wish to appoint Site Supervisors to supervise the City Council's highway construction works. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Principal Engineer - Asset Management

Liverpool City Council
£37,107 - £41,846
Liverpool City Council wish to recruit a Principal Engineer to assist in managing and maintaining highway and transport related assets Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Contracts Manager

Liverpool City Council
£37,107 - £41,846
Liverpool City Council wish to recruit a Contracts Manager based in Highways & Transportation. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Graduate Transport Planner

Cambridgeshire County Council
£17,681 - £23,111
EXCITING GRADUATE OPPORTUNITY Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Operations Manager

Camden London Borough Council
£48,332 - £59,073
This is an exciting time for Parking Operations at Camden Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Download your Highways App

Google App Apple App

Highways on Fridays

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Including:

  • Are you ready for the risk-based approach?
  • Pedestrian Power
  • Traffex Road Expo Scotland preview
View the latest issue

Latest Video