Amey loses Birmingham battle in Appeal Court

23/02/2018 |

The Court of Appeal has found in favour of Birmingham City Council and against Amey in a long running and occasionally bitter highways dispute, rejecting the company’s ‘ingenious new interpretation of the contract’.



Amey was contracted in 2010 to carry out a 25 year PFI contract for the city, and ‘all went well for the first three and a half years’ the Court reports.


However the partners fell out from 2014 onwards when it became clear the firm was not carrying out basic works the council felt it was obliged to do.


In a sign of how complex and bitter the dispute became, the Appeal Court documents refer to a 30-hour exchange of notes after one hearing ‘before the gunfire died down’.


Amey Birmingham Highways Ltd (ABHL) was ‘deliberately leaving the defects in selected areas untreated’ the court found and had ‘been carrying out works based on inaccurate inventory information’.


The firm argued that certain sections of the contractual inventory data, which established the nature and condition of the network under its care, did not have to be updated under the letter of its contract and therefore had stopped updates to a computer system known as the Project Network Model (PNM).


The court found: ‘Clause 5 of the contract required ABHL to satisfy themselves about the extent of the project network. That requirement only makes sense if ABHL were required to maintain the roads, footways, verges, kerbs and cycle tracks which actually existed.


‘If ABHL were going to work for the next 25 years on the original unamended inventory in the PNM, there would be no point in satisfying themselves about the extent of the project network which actually existed.’


The Court of Appeal reinstated judgements from a previous independent adjudicator in the case, whose decision Amey had initially overturned by a High Court Judgement in 2016.


The Court of Appeal made declarations ‘to the same effect as the declarations made by the adjudicator’, namely:


(i) That ABHL’s obligations to perform the Core Investment Works and meet the requirements of Performance Standard 1 extend to the Project Network as a whole and are not limited to the RSLs as recorded in the Project Network Model contained in DRD0626 [ the initial version of Project Network Model].


(ii) That ABHL must update the Project Network Model and maintain a Project Network Inventory which accurately reflects the actual extent of the Project Network and the Project Road.


(iii) That the Certificates of Completion for Milestones 6 to 9 inclusive be set aside, alternatively opened up, reviewed and revised and the relevant calculations performed again by reference to the actual Project Network Inventory.”


The judgement is also notable for the way it addresses the spirit as well as the letter of such long-term local government ‘relational contracts’. Lord Justice Jackson noted: ‘Any relational contract of this character is likely to be of massive length, containing many infelicities and oddities. Both parties should adopt a reasonable approach in accordance with what is obviously the long-term purpose of the contract. They should not be latching onto the infelicities and oddities, in order to disrupt the project and maximise their own gain.’


Cllr Stewart Stacey, Birmingham’s cabinet member for transport and roads, said: ‘This is a significant step for the council in our aim of getting the level of investment into our roads that we believe should have been provided by Amey during the first five years of the contract. It fully justifies our decision to appeal the High Court judgement from 2016 and we now need to move forward in light of the Appeal Court ruling in getting the condition of our roads and footways to the standard that the people of Birmingham expect and deserve.’


An Amey spokesperson said: ‘In 2010 Amey embarked on a 25-year highways contract with Birmingham City Council. Since then, we have delivered significant investment in the city’s roads, which has seen considerable improvements to the network.


‘We have resurfaced 500 miles of carriageway – over one-third of Birmingham’s roads – and over 400 miles of pedestrian footway. We’ve also replaced 42,000 street lights, and over half of the city’s traffic signal systems. Amey has made a significant investment to upgrade the road network in and around Birmingham. We have completed a comprehensive programme of investment as part of a major infrastructure initiative, and it is one of the most capital intensive projects in Europe.


‘We have been involved in a dispute with Birmingham City Council over the last 24 months regarding the scope of our contractual obligations in the core investment period. Unfortunately, despite the High Court having found in our favour previously the ruling was overturned by an appeal.


‘Amey is disappointed at the outcome of the case, and has been preparing for all outcomes. We are currently considering all options for next steps. We remain committed to the market and all our clients. The issues raised in this dispute were very specific to the contract and its structure.’

Highways InProfile

latest magazine issue
Highways jobs

Rights of Way Assistant

£28,797 - £30,708
Within the Highways Directorate we are looking to appoint enthusiastic, customer focused and experienced person to join the Service. Darley Dale, Matlock
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Project Design Engineer

Up to £0.0000 per annum
Project Design EngineerFixed Term, Full Time£37,559 to £44,186 per annum Location
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Project Design Engineer

Up to £0.0000 per annum
Project Design EngineerFixed Term, Full Time£37,559 to £44,186 per annumLocation
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Principal Transport Planner (Strategy)

£46,731-£49,764
We are looking for an experienced professional to join North Northamptonshire Council as a Principal Transport Planner (Strategy). Sheerness House, 41 Meadow Road, Kettering moving to Haylock House, Kettering Parkway, Kettering NN15 6EY, United Kingdom
Recruiter: North Northamptonshire Council

Highways Capital Delivery Manager

£50,788 - £52,805
To be responsible for the implementation of Welsh Government’s Renewal and Upgrade programme. Baglan, Port Talbot
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Engineer x 2

£47,532 –£55,620 per annum
Our people are deeply committed to providing excellent services to our residents, doing all we can to make lives as good as they can be. Hounslow (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hounslow London Borough Council

Electrical Design Engineer

Grade 9 £34,314 to £37,938 - Grade 10 £37,035 to £40,476 - Grade 11 £39,513 to £43,693 - Grade 12 £42,708 to £46,731 p.a.
The Construction Consultancy Services (CCS) team provide client-side construction consultancy services across a range of professional disciplines to d Durham
Recruiter: Durham County Council

Park Operations Assistant - Thorndon Country Park

Up to £12540.50 per annum
This is a permanent, part time position on an annualised hours contract. This means you will be contracted to work a minimum of 964.59 hours per yea England, Essex, Brentwood
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Senior Highways Engineer

£50,754 – £53,607 per annum
Our people are deeply committed to providing excellent services to our residents, doing all we can to make lives as good as they can be. Hounslow (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hounslow London Borough Council

Highways Capital Lead

£47,754 - £50,788
To be responsible for management of the Regional Highway Capital Delivery Teams South Wales
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Development Management Engineer

£37,938 - £44,711
In line with our One Coventry Values, we want to ensure that our communities are represented across our workforce Coventry, West Midlands
Recruiter: Coventry City Council

Head of Highways

£66,366 - £85,284 pa
Highway Operations is a large division within the Planning, Growth & Infrastructure. Enfield (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Enfield London Borough Council

Director Highways, Transport & Waste Management

up to £120k
There for Nottinghamshire. There for each other. There for you. Nottinghamshire
Recruiter: Nottinghamshire County Council

Director of Highways and Transportation

£126,909
We’re seeking a dynamic and innovative leader to spearhead our Highways and Transportation services. Essex
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Senior Structures Technician

£32,654 - £36,124 plus circa £2000 - £4000 OT (variable
To lead on the planning, delivery and reporting of the highway structures General Inspection programme. Baglan, Port Talbot
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Assistant Director of Place Operations

£85,962 to £93,267
Bury is a proud and prosperous borough Bury, Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Bury Council

Career Grade Transport Planner (Carer Grade 6-8)

Grade 06 (£29,093 - £32,654) TO Grade 08 (£37,938 - £41,511)
This is a fantastic opportunity to work for a forward thinking and dynamic transport authority located in the heart of the North West Warrington, Cheshire
Recruiter: Warrington Borough Council

Principal Performance and Assurance Manager

£Competitive
We have an exciting opportunity for a highly motivated Principal Performance and Assurance Manager to join our Senior Management Team SBIM Avonmouth, Bristol
Recruiter: Amey

Principal Construction Manager

£Competitive
We are excited to offer a fantastic opportunity for a Permanent Principal Construction Manager to join our dynamic Area 12 West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Amey

Electrician

£Competitive
We are excited to offer a fantastic opportunity for two Permanent Electricians Tingley, Wakefield
Recruiter: Amey
SUBSCRIBE NOW

Latest Video

Subscribe to Highways today to ensure you keep your finger on the pulse of everything happening in the UK road network throughout the year.

SUBSCRIBE NOW