Exclusive: A quarter of smart motorway schemes fall below safety benchmark

16/04/2024 | CHRIS AMES

One in four stopped vehicle detection (SVD) installations on smart motorways still failed to meet National Highways’ core performance requirements when re-tested last year.

This is despite National Highways’ official monitor, the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) reporting in December that ‘the latest data show that performance targets…are now being met’.

Against an 80% detection rate target, one scheme fell to a 66% over a 24-hour period, with four others between 70% and 78%.

In addition, when the additional requirement that vehicles should be detected within 20 seconds of stopping was applied, fewer than half of the schemes achieved the necessary success rate, with the worst achieving just 47%.

SVD technology uses radar to detect vehicles stopped on all lane running (ALR) smart motorways so that alerts can be set. Official statistics show that stationary vehicles on ALR schemes are at significantly higher risk than those on motorways with a hard shoulder.

As Highways reported at the time, the results that National Highways reported to the ORR last year were only achieved after it changed its methodology to the point where 85% of stopped vehicle events were excluded from its calculations.

 

This included events in the testing area where National Highways unilaterally determined that the vehicle was out of range of its radar system.

Although the ORR reported that National Highways was meeting its target of detecting 80% of stopped vehicles in four of five regions and nationally (89%), this concealed significant variations between the 21 schemes tested.

Highways has now obtained the scheme level data given to the ORR by National Highways. This shows that five schemes had detection rates of below 80% when their performance was examined by a ‘ground truthing’ approach whereby detections are compared against events seen on CCTV over a 24-hour period.

Four of these five schemes had detection rates ranging from 70% to 78% while one was just 67%. This was between junctions 39 and 42 and of the M1 in Yorkshire, where only 10 of the 15 events that were used for the calculation were detected.

AA president Edmund King said: 'The findings of this investigation by Highways are incredibly worrying and re-iterate our concerns that you can’t rely solely on technology to mitigate the inherent design faults of "smart" motorways.

'This is one of the reasons why the AA has put the scrapping of "smart" motorways as a major part of our motoring manifesto.'

The ORR told Highways that the data on detection rates was collected as part of the ground-truthing process over a 24h period, adding that it considered that small sample sizes mean that caution is required when drawing conclusions for individual schemes.

A spokesperson said: ‘This is why we have aggregated to regional and national level when reporting performance. In addition to the small sample sizes, there may be specific circumstances that have affected performance over the 24hr testing period.’

In fact, the testing did generate potentially much greater sample sizes but National Highways made its calculation based on only 15 % of events - due to the change in methodology.

The ORR also reported in December that National Highways had met its requirement for stopped vehicles to be detected within 20 seconds. As it pointed out, ‘the time to detect shall not exceed 20 seconds’, suggesting a detection after this time is effectively a failure.

On this basis, 11 of the 21 schemes tested last year detected less than 80% of stopped vehicle events within 20 seconds, with the scheme between junctions 16 and 19 of the M6 detecting just eight of 17 qualifying stopped vehicle events (47%) within the required time.

The ORR report stated that it had required National Highways to report on the ‘proportion of stopped vehicles that were correctly detected within 20 seconds’, which it said it considered ‘a better measurement of the technical requirement for SVD that the time to detect shall not exceed 20 seconds’.

It concluded: ‘This showed that 92% of stopped vehicles were detected within 20 seconds.’

This is not correct. This is not the percentage of total stopped vehicles that were detected within 20 seconds, but only the percentage of vehicles that the system managed to detect that were detected in under 20 seconds. 

Many genuine stopped vehicle events were not detected at all, and the ORR did not include these in its calculation. 

The ORR confirmed that this is a correct interpretation of its statement.

The ORR obtained the figure by dividing the number of vehicles detected within the timeframe by the number of vehicles detected. This therefore excluded from the calculation events that were missed altogether.

It told Highways that it did exclude missed detections on the basis that 'a detection time of 20 seconds or less can’t be achieved for stopped vehicles that are not detected'.

Highways has approached National Highways for comment.

Highways InProfile

latest magazine issue
Highways jobs

Principal Transport Planner (Strategy)

£46,731-£49,764
We are looking for an experienced professional to join North Northamptonshire Council as a Principal Transport Planner (Strategy). Sheerness House, 41 Meadow Road, Kettering moving to Haylock House, Kettering Parkway, Kettering NN15 6EY, United Kingdom
Recruiter: North Northamptonshire Council

Highways Capital Delivery Manager

£50,788 - £52,805
To be responsible for the implementation of Welsh Government’s Renewal and Upgrade programme. Baglan, Port Talbot
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Engineer x 2

£47,532 –£55,620 per annum
Our people are deeply committed to providing excellent services to our residents, doing all we can to make lives as good as they can be. Hounslow (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hounslow London Borough Council

Electrical Design Engineer

Grade 9 £34,314 to £37,938 - Grade 10 £37,035 to £40,476 - Grade 11 £39,513 to £43,693 - Grade 12 £42,708 to £46,731 p.a.
The Construction Consultancy Services (CCS) team provide client-side construction consultancy services across a range of professional disciplines to d Durham
Recruiter: Durham County Council

Park Operations Assistant - Thorndon Country Park

Up to £12540.50 per annum
This is a permanent, part time position on an annualised hours contract. This means you will be contracted to work a minimum of 964.59 hours per yea England, Essex, Brentwood
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Senior Highways Engineer

£50,754 – £53,607 per annum
Our people are deeply committed to providing excellent services to our residents, doing all we can to make lives as good as they can be. Hounslow (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hounslow London Borough Council

Highways Capital Lead

£47,754 - £50,788
To be responsible for management of the Regional Highway Capital Delivery Teams South Wales
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Development Management Engineer

£37,938 - £44,711
In line with our One Coventry Values, we want to ensure that our communities are represented across our workforce Coventry, West Midlands
Recruiter: Coventry City Council

Head of Highways

£66,366 - £85,284 pa
Highway Operations is a large division within the Planning, Growth & Infrastructure. Enfield (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Enfield London Borough Council

Director Highways, Transport & Waste Management

up to £120k
There for Nottinghamshire. There for each other. There for you. Nottinghamshire
Recruiter: Nottinghamshire County Council

Director of Highways and Transportation

£126,909
We’re seeking a dynamic and innovative leader to spearhead our Highways and Transportation services. Essex
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Senior Structures Technician

£32,654 - £36,124 plus circa £2000 - £4000 OT (variable
To lead on the planning, delivery and reporting of the highway structures General Inspection programme. Baglan, Port Talbot
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Assistant Director of Place Operations

£85,962 to £93,267
Bury is a proud and prosperous borough Bury, Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Bury Council

Career Grade Transport Planner (Carer Grade 6-8)

Grade 06 (£29,093 - £32,654) TO Grade 08 (£37,938 - £41,511)
This is a fantastic opportunity to work for a forward thinking and dynamic transport authority located in the heart of the North West Warrington, Cheshire
Recruiter: Warrington Borough Council

Principal Performance and Assurance Manager

£Competitive
We have an exciting opportunity for a highly motivated Principal Performance and Assurance Manager to join our Senior Management Team SBIM Avonmouth, Bristol
Recruiter: Amey

Principal Construction Manager

£Competitive
We are excited to offer a fantastic opportunity for a Permanent Principal Construction Manager to join our dynamic Area 12 West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Amey

Electrician

£Competitive
We are excited to offer a fantastic opportunity for two Permanent Electricians Tingley, Wakefield
Recruiter: Amey

Principal Engineer – Structures Capital Delivery

£43,693 - £47,754
To act as one of the Agent's technical experts for highway structures schemes and related issues South Wales
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Engineer Programme Management

£36,124 - £39,513
To support the Principal Engineer ensuring effective co-ordination, programming and contract administration. South Wales
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent

Senior Engineer – Structures Delivery

£36,124 - £39,513
To support the Principal Engineer Structures (Capital Works) and deputise if necessary South Wales
Recruiter: South Wales Trunk Road Agent
SUBSCRIBE NOW

Latest Video

Subscribe to Highways today to ensure you keep your finger on the pulse of everything happening in the UK road network throughout the year.

SUBSCRIBE NOW