ORR lets Highways England off the hook on safety pledge

31/07/2020
Dominic Browne and Chris Ames

The Office of Rail and Road (ORR) has said no action will be taken against Highways England despite the Government-owned company failing to meet a key safety commitment.

Highways England had pledged to ensure that the majority of those roads with a 1 and 2 iRAP/EuroRap safety rating would be improved to 3 stars over the first road investment strategy (RIS 1) period covering 2015-2020.

The commitment was made in the first Highways England delivery plan for the period but was quietly downplayed or dropped, and not mentioned in later delivery plans.

The roads authority admitted to Highways last year that it was struggling to meet the pledge.

Now Highways can reveal that the ORR had no intention of holding Highways England to account over the target, as it had decided behind the scenes the commitment was 'undeliverable'.

Based on an understanding of how ORR monitors Highways England this conclusion was almost certainly arrived at between the parties, rather than ORR deciding on its own.

An ORR spokesman said: 'In line with our duties as set out in the Infrastructure Act, we take a proportionate and targeted approach to monitoring Highways England. This means that we do not investigate every area of Highways England’s activities in detail.

'In the case of how it prioritises safety investments relating to the star rating of the network, it became clear in Road Period 1 that the commitment to increase the majority of 1 and 2 star roads was undeliverable. Part of the point of our monitoring is to ensure that targets are realistic.

'We’re clear that Highways England could be doing more and we will be monitoring the company to see that it does this in Road Period 2. We will report on the progress it makes in this area during RP2.'

The news comes after the regulator was forced to backtrack on claims that Highways England had ‘demonstrated that it is applying an evidence-based approach’ to improving safety.

ORR effectively admitted it had taken Highways England at its word over the assertion and conceded it had not 'demonstrated' this but merely 'stated' it.

In ORR's annual assessment of Highways England this year it gave a review of its performance over RIS 1 (2015-2020). It said: 'Highways England has not met its commitment to improve the majority of 1-star and 2-star roads to 3-star or more by 2020. In response to this, the company has explained to ORR that it takes account of both the star rating, and statistical risk of death or serious injury, of a road when prioritising safety interventions.

'We recognise that targeting its finite resources in this way can help the company achieve a greater reduction in casualties than if it focused on improving star ratings alone.'

ORR has not given an explanation as to how it came to the conclusion the target was 'undeliverable' or what trade-offs would have been necessary to make it happen.

Highways is still awaiting a response to these questions.

ORR can levy fines of up to £25m against Highways England.

In its enforcement policy, ORR states a serious contravention might involve 'significant responsibility on Highways England’s part and continuing failure by Highways England to adequately address and put in place action plans to remedy the issue'.

'The contravention may form part of a wider sustained, systemic or persistent failure, and there may be the potential for further similar harm to be repeated if the problems are not addressed.'

At a 'serious' contravention level, ORR would normally impose a fine of up to £2.5m.

A very serious contravention could result in a fine of up to £25m and might involve 'significant harm, or the risk of significant harm, being caused to a wide range of third parties and/or greater culpability on the part of the Highways England, for example, where Highways England was intentionally misleading'.

A recent report from the Road Safety Foundation concluded that both the company’s target of a 40% cut in killed and seriously injured (KSI) casualties by the end of 2020 and the long-term goal of no one being killed or injured on the strategic road network (SRN) by 2040 ‘are unlikely to be met by current activity’.

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Also Inside:

  • Cold Comfort Scotland Review
  • Traffic Signals Backlog Revealed
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Principal Transport Development Planner

£39,759 per annum (pro rata if part time)
A great opportunity to join the Suffolk County Council's Transport Strategy Team as a Principal Transport Development Planner. Suffolk County Council, Ipswich IP1 2BX
Recruiter: Suffolk County Council

Senior Manager - Asset and Network

£56,593 - £62,792
This is a brand-new role developed out of our vision for the future of the recently established Transport and Highways directorate. Chester, Ellesmere Port, Winsford
Recruiter: Cheshire West & Chester

Senior Manager - Highways and Environment

£56,593 - £62,792
This is a brand-new role developed out of our vision for the future of the recently established Transport and Highways directorate. Chester, Ellesmere Port, Winsford
Recruiter: Cheshire West & Chester

Principal Green Infrastructure Officer

Grade
£40,578 - £44,624
Recruiter: Basingstoke & Deane BC

Sustainable Travel Planning Officer

£28,226 - £30,095
Sustainable Travel Planning Officer
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Sustainable Travel Planning Manager

£34,408 - £37,108
The Planning and Sustainable Growth Service is looking to recruit an experienced and enthusiastic Sustainable Travel Planning Manager New Shire Hall - Alconbury Weald
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Capital Delivery Manager

£43,910 to £50,504
City of York Council are excited to announce that we are seeking a Capital Delivery Manager. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

HGV Driver

£11.60 per hour
Our client has a great opportunity for HGV/LGV drivers to work in the Waste Recycling service. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Flood Risk Officer

£23,953 - £26,466
Lincolnshire County Council has established a national reputation for its partnership approach to managing flood risk. Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Household Waste Recycling Centre Operative

£18,887 - £20,043
We are looking for someone who enjoys working with the public and works well as part of a team. Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Household Waste Recycling Centre Supervisor

£23,953 - £26,466
An exciting new position in Waste Services is waiting for you! Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Waste Performance and Improvement Assistant

£20,043 - £21,269
You will be integral in supporting the seven District Councils across Lincolnshire to improve the quality of waste disposed of by residents. Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Senior Planning Liaison Officer

£30,984 to £35,336
We’re looking for somebody to join our Highways and Transport team as a Senior Planning Liaison Officer. Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Senior Performance Analyst

£50,810 - £59,408
This role can be based at any of our locations
Recruiter: Office of Rail and Road (ORR)

Loaders (Morpeth)

£18,887 - £19,264
You will provide an efficient and effective refuse collection and recycling service. Morpeth, Northumberland
Recruiter: Northumberland County Council

Senior Technician - Highway Drainage Management (2 Posts)

£26,204 - £28,113
The Highway Drainage Management Team is a newly formed team within the Highways Service. Matlock, Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Parking and Processing Assistant

£20,444
Northumberland County Council operates a huge range of services across one of the largest counties in the UK. Northumberland
Recruiter: Northumberland County Council

Principal Engineer - York Central

£37,114 to £42,562
We have an exciting opening for an experienced highway design engineer. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Senior Highway Adoptions Inspector

£31,887 to £36,380
We have an exciting opening for an experienced highway inspector. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Highways Asset Engineer

£37,260 - £38,148
Are you an experienced Asset Management professional looking for your next challenge? Hackney, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hackney London Borough Council

Highways Presents

 

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video