Analysis: Problems with Specification

08/09/2020

Ian Thomas (pictured) of the Association for Road Traffic Safety and Management (ARTSM) and chair of the BSI B/509/10 Subcommittee for Breakaway Safety, discusses the importance of specifying adequately when ordering road signs.

In 1994, all member states of the EU joined with the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) to form a new body called the European Economic Area (EEA).

The purpose of the EEA was to strengthen trade and economic relations between the nations and was primarily concerned with upholding the four fundamental pillars of the European internal market, namely the free movement of goods, people, services and capital.

The EEA comprised 31 nations and the general idea was that it allowed organisations in any member nation to freely compete on a level playing field across the EEA for contracts issued by public authorities.

This move to the principles of ‘free trade’ meant the old prescriptive standards that were in place for many years made freely competing for a public tender by suppliers from another part of the EEA almost impossible, so they were slowly phased out and replaced by performance based standards.

Little did anyone know how difficult this slight change would be for manufacturers and suppliers.

 

Prescriptive Standards

Prescriptive standards are very much like recipes: do this, do that, then something else and if you follow the instructions, competing suppliers will end up supplying pretty much the same product or service because they have to follow the same rules. There will always be nuances between competing suppliers, but these are only slight differences.

It is also worth noting that prescriptive standards were almost always written by civil servants with no affinity to a particular product or service, who also had considerable experience in their chosen field and were considered as experts and held in very high regard by their peers in industry.

Performance Standards

Performance standards are completely different in that they aren’t recipes; they just define the required outcome by a specifier. They don’t tell a supplier how to manufacture a product or supply a service; they just tell the supplier what they finally want to achieve.

Using the example of a vacuum cleaner, the difference between a prescriptive specification and a performance specification is that with the former the specifier would state exactly what size motor they want; by contrast, a performance specification would tell the supplier what kind of suction is required at the other end and then it is pretty much up to the supplier to decide how to design the product to meet the objectives.

Performance standards are almost always written by committee and the members are normally from the Test Houses of Europe or the larger companies who manufacture/supply that specific product or service

The Need for Specification

Throughout this article, I will use the example of a road traffic sign to demonstrate the need for a properly written specification. However, whatever products or service are required by a specifier, the need for a defined specification is exactly the same.

In the old days, it used to be really simple to provide a product or service against a prescriptive standard.

A specifier would say that they wanted the sign to comply with Diagram X of TSRGD and everything to be manufactured to BS873:1984 Part 7 and that was pretty much it. The sign manufacturer knew what to produce and the signpost supplier knew what was required and it all came together for the installation team to assemble at site.

The specifier got what they wanted; all manufacturers knew what was required and everybody went away happy with a job usually well done.

In the days of performance standards, it isn’t quite so easy as it all depends on what the customer actually wants. With the advent of BS EN 12899-1:2007 replacing BS873:1984, there are now in excess of 127 million different combinations of performance classification just for a Road Traffic Sign and its supporting post.

This is made very much worse as a number of the performance classifications include “No Performance Determined”, i.e. nothing has been structurally determined so the whole assembly may not actually be fit for purpose.

In theory, if a customer said in their tender documents that they wanted the sign to comply with Diagram X of TSRGD and everything to be manufactured just to BS EN 12899-1:2007, they could actually end up with a traffic sign printed on RA1 Engineering Grade material, stuck to a plywood backing with blu-tak and mounted on a piece of plastic drainpipe or scaffolding tube!

This would clearly not be fit for purpose and would likely result in an argument, but the specifier would be totally at fault because it didn’t provide a complete specification for its requirements to be met.

The suppliers have ultimately complied with what was specified and they have offered a product with the lowest performance classifications, so the specifiers wouldn’t really have a leg to stand on.

In reality though, this extreme scenario is unlikely to happen as the sign manufacturers and post suppliers are extremely professional and would ask probing questions of the customer specification prior to supply, but it does demonstrate the need and purpose of correct specification. CE Marking

This brings us on to CE marking and the misnomer that something with a CE mark is a quality product.

The CE certification is in reality just a checklist against the clauses of a standard and does not prove that any particular product is fit for a given scenario.

Under European and UK Law, the Construction Products Regulations (originally 89/106/EEC, superseded by Regulation (EU) No 305/2011 dated 9 March 2011) is a mandatory requirement that any product covered by a harmonised European standard is CE certified with an accompanying Declaration of Performance (DOP) issued by the manufacturer.

The DOP is the important piece of documentation, as this states the performance classifications related to the specific product standard that are actually attained by the product in question.

Where CE marking of a product falls down is that if there are no performance criteria laid down in the harmonized standard to actually measure against it is not possible to CE certify that product against the specific product standard.

An example of this conundrum would be sign lights and sign fixings as there are no measurable performance criteria for either product type laid down in BS EN12899-1:2007.

Also, not all products are covered by harmonized standards. Particular examples of this are traffic bollards, temporary road signs and zebra crossing beacons amongst others; these products are all actually covered by the British Standard BS 8442:2015.

This standard does have some performance criteria stipulated within it so a DOP can be supplied by the manufacturer if required, but it won’t have the CE mark of a European harmonized standard.

National Annex of a Harmonised Standard

If a specifier is a little unsure of the exact detail required in specifying a performance specification (there is after all a lot to take on board), it is recommended that the specifier writes in its tender documentation that it wants the sign to comply with Diagram X of TSRGD and everything to be manufactured to the current UK National Annex to BS EN 12899-1:2007.

This will ensure that the finished sign and post combination when installed will at least be fit for purpose, unlike the scenario described previously.

The downside of this approach to specification is that the finished installation will be over-engineered and more costly than if offering a full-blown written specification to to work against.

Incorrect Specifications

The way the Performance standards are written, it is possible that products or services may not be actually commercially available for a given specification.

A prime example of this is the requirement for High Energy Passively Safe signpost on 70mph roads being written into specification – this is not only commercially unavailable, but is physically unavailable as well, as a signpost isn’t sufficiently long to wrap around and slow an errant vehicle to the required lower speeds, whilst still attaining the same AISI and THIV values that the standard dictates.

ARTSM Working Group 3 recently held a virtual meeting about, amongst other things, fixed VMS signs. One member complained that their company had received a poorly written specification that caused major confusion and anxiety within their estimating team.

The specifiers had written the customer specification in such a way that the border size around the sign face could have been interpreted very differently. In the worst case, the sign would have been very much bigger than if interpreted the other way, resulting in a differential in cost of several thousand pounds per unit to the purchaser.

If the manufacturer had just offered the lower priced version, this may not have been what the customer wanted, but equally, if it had gone in at the higher price, it may have lost the contract completely, hence the anxiety and confusion.

The way projects work in the UK these days, it is extremely difficult for a manufacturer/supplier to talk directly to a customer to understand their exact needs if there is a poorly written specification doing the rounds on a particular project.

By the time that the manufacturer/supplier has gone back to their customer, usually the installer, with questions, who has then fed back to the scheme agent, who has then fed back to the design team for a decision to be made and then the information sent right back through the supply chain the other way, on complicated schemes this can and does take many weeks, leading to delay and more cost.

Conclusion

What I’m really trying to get at is for specifiers to specify exactly what they want and then the whole process of supplying a product or service is much easier.

I suppose an analogy is if I ask my wife to get me a cake when she is out. I might think she’s bringing me a chocolate cake with cream and cherries on top, but if she brings a cup cake, I’ve only got myself to blame for not being specific!

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

INSIDE:

  • COP26: The sector reacts
  • Road pricing: Putting the theory into practice
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Highways Projects Manager

Up to £38,326.08 p.a.
We are looking for an experienced, skilled and competent Highways Projects Manager to help deliver a wide range of... Broxbourne, Hertfordshire
Recruiter: Broxbourne Borough Council

Assistant Director of Environment and Regulatory Services

circa £84,000
As Assistant Director of Environment and Regulatory Services, you will be responsible for core ‘front-line’ place-based services, including... Bolton, Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council

Heads of Service

£57,636 - £58,509 pa
It’s an exciting time to join us here in West Lancs as we are looking for 3 inspirational leaders who have the energy and drive to... Lancashire
Recruiter: West Lancashire Borough Council

Senior Engineer- Highways

£23,080- £30,451
Our Highways Service is growing to reflect the increase in investment. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Environmental Data Officer

£26,592
In this role you will collect, maintain and manage high quality energy and environmental data, and providing... Camden, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Camden London Borough Council

Senior Engineer - Highways Asset Maintenance

£39,854 to £43,741 (Pay Award Pending)
There’s never been a more exciting time to join Doncaster Council. Doncaster, South Yorkshire
Recruiter: Doncaster Council

Director of Environmental & Community Services

Up to £90,096 per annum
We seek an energetic and committed Director who has the right motivations and values; someone who is... Long Eaton, Nottingham
Recruiter: Erewash Borough Council

Transport Infrastructure Commissioning Officer

£30,451 to £34,728 per annum
We have a great opportunity in Somerset to join our Highways and Transport Service. Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Team Manager Band 3 – Environment Strategy & Change

£46,845 - £48,849 per annum
This is the perfect time to join St Helens and become part of our exhilarating journey and help build our legacy for the future. St Helens, Merseyside
Recruiter: St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council

Noise and Nuisance Officer

£32,301 - £35,949 per annum
To be successful in the Noise and Nuisance Team you will need a genuine commitment to... Kensington and Chelsea, London (Greater)
Recruiter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

Team Manager Band 3 - Fleet, Depot & Security

£46,845 - £48,849 per annum
This is the perfect time to join St Helens and become part of our exhilarating journey and help build our legacy for the future. St Helens, Merseyside
Recruiter: St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council

Minibus Driver

Hourly rate
North Yorkshire County Council
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Minibus Driver

Hourly rate
North Yorkshire County Council
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Minibus Driver

Hourly rate
North Yorkshire County Council
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Minibus Driver

Hourly rate
North Yorkshire County Council
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Minibus Driver

Hourly rate
North Yorkshire County Council
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Asset Manager

£42,821 - £46,845 per annum
The Highway Asset Manager is responsible for the strategic management of all the council’s highway assets... Blackburn, Lancashire
Recruiter: Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council

Digital Evidence Officer

£25.137 - £26.520
The Digital Evidence (CCTV) Team are responsible for improving community safety outcomes throughout the Royal Borough of Greenwich by... Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Guaranteed Relief Cleaners North and South Kirklees Area

£9.25 per hour
Some of the key features and benefits of being part of the Kirklees Cleaning Service include... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Group Engineer - Safety Design

£40,876 - £45,859
We are looking for an experienced engineer to join our Highways Safety Design team. Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Highways Presents

 

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video