DfT report struggles to appraise local maintenance

10/10/2024 | DOMINIC BROWNE

DfT report struggles to appraise local maintenance

A Government report on the economic benefits of investing in local highways maintenance found that the funding and reporting landscape is so complex any strategic appraisal was all but impossible.

The Department for Transport (DfT) commissioned AtkinsRéalis following an internal review, which recommended 'DfT take additional steps to assess and demonstrate the Value for Money (VfM) of the funding at a wider programme level'.

The review – Economic appraisal for investing in local highways maintenance – aimed to demonstrate the Benefit Cost Ratio (BCR) and Value for Money (VfM) of investing in local maintenance. It could also inform the Spending Review next spring.

It notes that 'overall, funding for local highways maintenance provides good to very good return on investment, with socioeconomic benefits estimated to provide up to £5+ return on £1 investment' and that 'research findings are unanimous in framing local highway maintenance as a good investment'.

However, there is 'little understanding of how to quantify and communicate many of the benefits as current tools and guidance only focus on a certain subset of monetised benefits'.

'BCRs and VfM of local highways maintenance is likely to vary considerably across different regions and different types of assets and even for different investment strategies on a single network section,' it states.

'Therefore, a direct assessment of a national level of VfM of maintenance may not be as informative as it would first appear. The outcome would be likely to enable only a binary decision of whether funds should be targeted at maintenance or not, but with no facility to inform a strategy of how much funding should be invested, where, or over what period of time.'

The report found that 'the assets that provide the foundations of the road network all need to be treated and assessed differently in relation to the inputs they require and how they influence the overall network'.

'All the key assets of the network are inter-connected and always have some level of overlap. Being able to break down the benefits and costs that are tied to each asset class is a complex task that is best represented through the comparison of schemes relative to the impacts of no intervention.'

When it comes to assessing 'preferred strategies at a local level', there had been significant investment in tools such as Highway Maintenance Appraisal Toolkit (HMAT) published in 2015 and the Highway Maintenance Economic Assessment (HMEA) from 2021, both of which were created by the Transport Research Laboratory (TRL).

However, the report found their use is 'somewhat limited at a local authority level due to a lack of experience or confidence in their use and concerns over budget to employ consultants'.

It notes that simplified models or tools requiring less input could be beneficial but potentially unreliable.

The review made similar findings to previous analysis from the Transport Select Committee and the RAC Foundation about the lack of clarity in local highways funding.

The AtkinsRéalis report states: 'How much money each local authority spends on highway maintenance annually or how that compares to funding allocated for that purpose is unclear.

'Local authorities do not formally report on actual maintenance budgets, so collating information of this nature requires significant effort. This also results in budget and spend data that is inconsistently produced and of potentially low levels of accuracy, comparability and national coverage.

'Funding streams themselves are inconsistent and currently uncertain from year to year, making long term planning near-impossible.'

Recommendations

The report calls for:

  • Introduction of an incentivisation scheme for use of new or additional highways maintenance funding. Additionally, engage with stakeholders such as MHCLG and ADEPT to test the appetite for influencing revenue funding.
  • Introduction of the digital data collection portal proposed during original State of the Nation project. This will allow for up-to-date and consistent data to be collected and could also be used to collect budget and spend data as part of an incentivisation system.
  • Review potential to formally expand guidance for monetisation of some or all of the wider benefits identified in this report. Also, engage with industry groups such as UKRLG, ADEPT, CIHT, PIARC to gather further information on existing highway maintenance business cases.
  • Define the desired scope for the appraisal of local highways maintenance (e.g., at network whole, network asset or scheme level). Once scope is selected, this will drive selection of options.
  • Develop suite of tools to maximise impact of any appraisals, such as development of wider learning and engagement resources beyond highway maintenance specialists, which could include comms toolkit, guidance on consistent reporting, and reporting of DRC [Depreciated Replacement Cost] asset valuation.

Highways InProfile

latest magazine issue
Highways jobs

Director of Transport

£112,924
East Midlands Combined County Authority (EMCCA) is on a bold journey. East Midlands Region
Recruiter: East Midlands Combined County Authority

Ferry Host - WMF3049i

£25,584 - £25,992
Ferry Host - WMF3049i Windermere, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Director of Streetscene

£94,972 - £108,767
We continue to have big ambitions for our borough Fareham, Hampshire
Recruiter: Fareham Borough Council

Principal Engineer - Urban Traffic Control (UTC)

£44,711 - £49,764
Liverpool is home to vibrant, energetic and engaged communities. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Roadworker/Driver

Grade 6 £25,183 - £25,638 per annum (Pay Award Pending)
We’re looking for Roadworker/trainee LGV drivers to be part of our team Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Project Chargehand (2 Posts)

Grade 9 £31,344 - £33,253 per annum (Pay Award Pending)
We’re looking for experienced Project Chargehands to be part of the Highways Construction Services team Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Lawyer 2- Planning and Highways

£49,764 - £54,181
We are looking for a fresh thinking and enthusiastic Planning and Highways Lawyer Hereford, Herefordshire
Recruiter: Herefordshire Council

Development Engineer

£35,967 - £41,268 per annum
Are you ready to play a key role in shaping and safeguarding the future of our highways and public spaces? Bexley (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Bexley

Professional Services Partnering Manager

Grade 13 £47,653 - £51,296 per annum (pay award pending)
We are seeking a dynamic and experienced Professional Services Partnering Manager to lead the strategic management Darley Dale, Matlock
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Technical Supervision Manager

Grade 13 £47,653 - £51,296 per annum (pay award pending)
We are looking for an experienced and driven Technical Supervision Manager to lead our technical supervision teams within the Highways Service. Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Street Lighting Electrician (CDC)

Grade 8, £32,662 - £36,239 (pay award pending)
Highways Operations is a growing service area within the Place directorate. Doncaster, South Yorkshire
Recruiter: City Of Doncaster Council

Highways Assistant Engineer WMF2133e

£39,513 to £40,476
We have an exciting opportunity for the right person to work within the challenging and ever-changing landscape. Penrith, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Highways Inspector/NRSWA

£36,345 - £40,344
We are looking for an organised and self-motivated individual to join our Streetworks Team based in Hackney Central. Hackney, London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Hackney Council

Structures Commissioner

Grade 14 £53,166 - £59,080 per annum (Pay Award Pending)
We are seeking an experienced and strategic leader to join our team as the Structures Commissioner. Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Team Leader Network Co-ordination

£51,429 - £58,140
As Team Leader for Network Coordination, you’ll manage a team that oversees all works and events on our public highways. Kensington and Chelsea, London (Greater)
Recruiter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

PRINCIPAL TRANSPORT PLANNING OFFICER

£43693 - £46731
We have an exciting opportunity for an experienced professional to join our team in Hull as a Principal Transport Planning Officer. Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recruiter: Hull City Council

HIGHWAYS AND TRAFFIC ENGINEER - 4 POSTS

£43693 - £46731
We have several exciting opportunities for suitably qualified Highways Civil Engineers and Traffic Engineers Wilson Centre, 1st floor, Hull HU1 2AG
Recruiter: Hull City Council

Principal Transport Planner

£45,718 to £49,764
Do you have considerable experience in the transport strategy and policy, and are you looking for your next career development opportunity? Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Recruiter: Sheffield City Council

Project Lead - Bridges and Structures WMF3037e

£45,718 to £46,731
We are currently seeking to recruit a Project Lead to join our Bridges and Structures team Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council
SUBSCRIBE NOW

Latest Video

Subscribe to Highways today to ensure you keep your finger on the pulse of everything happening in the UK road network throughout the year.

SUBSCRIBE NOW