Injuries increase on smart motorway scheme

Chris Ames

A new report on a smart motorway section of the M1 has revealed that the absolute number of personal injury collisions rose during the last two years of the period studied to a level higher than the annual average before the scheme opened.

National Highways excluded casualty figures for the fourth and fifth years from its five-years-after post opening project evaluation of the dynamic hard shoulder (DHS) scheme between junctions 10 and 13 of the M1, which opened in December 2012.

It is not clear why this happened. Although the report cites the change in casualty severity reporting that took place in 2016, this only affected the balance between serious and slight casualties, not the overall number of personal injury collisions or the number of collisions resulting in fatalities.

However, the report does disclose that there were an annual average of 95 personal injury collisions over the five-year period after the scheme was operational compared with 98 before the scheme.

The total number of such incidents in the first three years after opening was 272. Based on the annual average of 95, there were 475 incidents over five years, meaning that during the last two years there were a total of 203 incidents, an average of 101.5. This is therefore higher than the pre-scheme annual average of 98.

The figures appear to support the idea that collision rates on smart motorways increase as the additional space produced by the extra lane, which is temporary in dynamic hard shoulder running, is taken up by additional traffic.

A one-year after opening evaluation of smart motorway schemes between junctions 28 and 35a of the M1 states that 'traffic levels are set to increase in later years' and acknowledges the possibility that this could impact initially positive safety data.

Although the report does not appear to give traffic volumes for each year after opening, it does show that they increased overall, from an average 5,700 vehicles per hour in the pm peak (1,900 vehicles per lane as a three-lane motorway) to 6,300 vehicles per hour, which was 2,100 vehicles per as a three-lane motorway but just under 1,600 vehicles per lane with the fourth lane in operation.

The increase in traffic volumes meant that casualty rates per vehicle kilometre improved to a greater extent than indicated by absolute casualty figures.

The report also discloses that the number of serious collisions nearly doubled from 19 in the three years before the scheme was built to 32 in the three years after opening. This was not affected by the change in reporting.

It also states that there were five more collisions leading to serious injuries per year after the scheme, although this may have been affected by reporting changes.

The number of fatalities was three (an average of one a year), which was the same as in the three year period before work started on the scheme. No fatality figure is given for the fourth and fifth years, although a separate report shows that a further fatal collision occurred in the fifth year.

The two reports came to light following an FOI request from Highways. Transport minister Baroness Vere told the Transport Select Committee in June that she hoped to supply the reports in approximately two weeks but their publication stalled since then.

It was released at the same time as an evaluation by the Office of Rail and Road of Highways England’s use of statistics, which found that although the government-owned company had made no fundamental errors there is a limited amount of data available.

In 2019, there were only 141 miles of all lane running motorway (ALR), the network having expanded from 29 miles in 2014, which means that only 29 miles of ALR has a full five years’ worth of data.

The ORR also found that high-level statistics making comparisons between conventional motorways and smart motorways did not always separate the types of road between controlled motorways, DHS and, ALR ‘which may have obscured the impact of the removal of the hard shoulder’.

DHS schemes, which are to be phased out, operate as conventional motorways for most of the time and calculating the overall safety performance of DHS schemes is likely to dilute any reduction in safety that arises when the hard shoulder is used as a running lane.

This effect may be increased by the fact that when used as a conventional motorway, DHS schemes have the additional benefit of emergency refuge areas, which allow some drivers to leave the hard shoulder in an emergency.

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue


Highways Awards 2021 finalists revealed

Harris leads National Highways into new era

View the latest issue

Highways jobs

Street Works Co-ordinator

£21,153 - £23,791
Do you want to make a difference to how Street Works are managed within Lincolnshire? Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Principal Transport Planning Officer

£44,863 - £46,845. In addition, re-location expenses may also be paid.
This is an exciting opportunity to join the Strategic Transport Planning Team at Gloucestershire County Council (GCC). Gloucester, Gloucestershire
Recruiter: Gloucestershire County Council

Group Engineer - Highways Network Management

£40,876 - £45,859 Plus market rate supplement of £3,000, reviewed annually
We are looking for a Group Engineer who will support the recovery from the pandemic. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Group Engineer - Safety Design

£40,876 - £45,859 Plus market rate supplement of £3,000, reviewed annually
We are looking for an experienced engineer to join our Highways Safety Design team. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Highways Asset Management Engineer

£30,451 - £32,234 per annum
The post holder will... Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Senior Traffic Engineer

£32,910 - £35,745 per annum
This is an exciting opportunity to join Telford & Wrekin Council’s Highway Network Management Team to... Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Traffic Signals Engineer

£25,991 - £35,745
An exciting opportunity has arisen for a Technician/Engineer to join the Traffic Signals Systems & Operations (TSSO) team as a Career Grade Engineer. Lincoln, Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Transport and Procurement Manager

£48,194 - £52,980 per annum
Are you a Transport Manager looking for a role that is a break from the norm? Andover, Hampshire
Recruiter: Test Valley Borough Council

Traffic Engineers (Highway Design and Asset Management)

£32,910 – £35,745 per annum - fixed term for 5 years
We are looking for highly motivated and enthusiastic people to join our Traffic Engineering team. Halifax, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council

Street Lighting Design Engineer

£18,812 - £35,745
This is an exciting opportunity for you to join Lincolnshire County Council's Street Lighting Team as a Street Lighting Design Engineer. Lincoln, Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Project Engineers

£36,922 per annum (Grade H-I)
West Berkshire Council are looking for innovative, enthusiastic and focused Project Engineers. Newbury, Berkshire
Recruiter: West Berkshire Council

Charge Hand (Highways)

£24,943 to £27,067 per annum
We are looking for motivated individuals who are willing to contribute to the team’s growth and success. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Principal Highways Drainage Engineer

£32,910 - £35,745 per annum
Do you want to take a leading role maintaining a large network of assets? Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Cleaner Streets and Waste Contract Manager - Communities

£48,809 - £49,794 per annum
Responsible for managing the street cleansing, household waste collections services and community recycling centres Bridgend (Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr)
Recruiter: Bridgend County Borough Council

Senior Engineer Flood & Drainage

£40,876 - £45,859
We make a difference to the environment we live in. Come and help us manage our blue infrastructure. Bracknell, Berkshire
Recruiter: Bracknell Forest Borough Council

Business Support Officer – Passenger Transport

£20,092 - £21,748
You will assist the wider team in ensuring the office functions are delivered in a timely and accurate manner. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Senior Engineer

£31,339 to £35,754 per annum
We are looking for enthusiastic and motivated individuals who are willing to contribute to the teams growth and success. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Waste Collection Operative - Loaders / HGV Drivers (Hays Recruitment)

Competitive Salary
Hays are excited to be working in partnership with Chelmsford City Council who are always looking to expand their teams and are looking for... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Highways Presents

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video