Injuries increase on smart motorway scheme

08/09/2021
Chris Ames

A new report on a smart motorway section of the M1 has revealed that the absolute number of personal injury collisions rose during the last two years of the period studied to a level higher than the annual average before the scheme opened.

National Highways excluded casualty figures for the fourth and fifth years from its five-years-after post opening project evaluation of the dynamic hard shoulder (DHS) scheme between junctions 10 and 13 of the M1, which opened in December 2012.

It is not clear why this happened. Although the report cites the change in casualty severity reporting that took place in 2016, this only affected the balance between serious and slight casualties, not the overall number of personal injury collisions or the number of collisions resulting in fatalities.

However, the report does disclose that there were an annual average of 95 personal injury collisions over the five-year period after the scheme was operational compared with 98 before the scheme.

The total number of such incidents in the first three years after opening was 272. Based on the annual average of 95, there were 475 incidents over five years, meaning that during the last two years there were a total of 203 incidents, an average of 101.5. This is therefore higher than the pre-scheme annual average of 98.

The figures appear to support the idea that collision rates on smart motorways increase as the additional space produced by the extra lane, which is temporary in dynamic hard shoulder running, is taken up by additional traffic.

A one-year after opening evaluation of smart motorway schemes between junctions 28 and 35a of the M1 states that 'traffic levels are set to increase in later years' and acknowledges the possibility that this could impact initially positive safety data.

Although the report does not appear to give traffic volumes for each year after opening, it does show that they increased overall, from an average 5,700 vehicles per hour in the pm peak (1,900 vehicles per lane as a three-lane motorway) to 6,300 vehicles per hour, which was 2,100 vehicles per as a three-lane motorway but just under 1,600 vehicles per lane with the fourth lane in operation.

The increase in traffic volumes meant that casualty rates per vehicle kilometre improved to a greater extent than indicated by absolute casualty figures.

The report also discloses that the number of serious collisions nearly doubled from 19 in the three years before the scheme was built to 32 in the three years after opening. This was not affected by the change in reporting.

It also states that there were five more collisions leading to serious injuries per year after the scheme, although this may have been affected by reporting changes.

The number of fatalities was three (an average of one a year), which was the same as in the three year period before work started on the scheme. No fatality figure is given for the fourth and fifth years, although a separate report shows that a further fatal collision occurred in the fifth year.

The two reports came to light following an FOI request from Highways. Transport minister Baroness Vere told the Transport Select Committee in June that she hoped to supply the reports in approximately two weeks but their publication stalled since then.

It was released at the same time as an evaluation by the Office of Rail and Road of Highways England’s use of statistics, which found that although the government-owned company had made no fundamental errors there is a limited amount of data available.

In 2019, there were only 141 miles of all lane running motorway (ALR), the network having expanded from 29 miles in 2014, which means that only 29 miles of ALR has a full five years’ worth of data.

The ORR also found that high-level statistics making comparisons between conventional motorways and smart motorways did not always separate the types of road between controlled motorways, DHS and, ALR ‘which may have obscured the impact of the removal of the hard shoulder’.

DHS schemes, which are to be phased out, operate as conventional motorways for most of the time and calculating the overall safety performance of DHS schemes is likely to dilute any reduction in safety that arises when the hard shoulder is used as a running lane.

This effect may be increased by the fact that when used as a conventional motorway, DHS schemes have the additional benefit of emergency refuge areas, which allow some drivers to leave the hard shoulder in an emergency.

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Also Inside:

  • Cold Comfort Scotland Review
  • Traffic Signals Backlog Revealed
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Bridge Engineer - Kendal

£35,745 - £36,922
We are currently seeking to recruit an experienced and enthusiastic Bridge Engineer, to join our Bridges team based in either Kendal. Cumbria
Recruiter: Cumbria County Council

Highways Team Leader - Barrow

£25,927 - £26,446
Are you a hard-working and experienced Highways operative, looking for the next step in your career? Cumbria
Recruiter: Cumbria County Council

Rights of Way Officer

£28,226 - £30,095
The Rights of Way Officer role is based within the Highways Service. Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Transportation Planner

£35,336 - £39,571
A Transportation Planner is required for the analysis and monitoring of traffic. Pembrokeshire (Sir Benfro)
Recruiter: Pembrokeshire County Council

Traffic Regulation and Administration Officer

£24563 - £25823 per annum + generous pension, flex working + much more
OverviewWe are looking for a Traffic Regulation and Administration Officer to join the team and support us in delivering the parking service across Bu England, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Buckinghamshire Council

Civil Enforcement Officer

£22332 - £23478 per annum + generous pension, flex working + much more
OverviewAn exciting opportunity has arisen within Parking Services, which forms part of the Highways & Technical Services department in Buckinghamshir England, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Buckinghamshire Council

Fleet Management Team Leader

£42698 - £44888 per annum
OverviewWe are looking to recruit an experienced and motivated Team Leader to lead Buckinghamshire Council's Fleet Management Team which provides vehi England, Buckinghamshire, Aylesbury
Recruiter: Buckinghamshire Council

Senior Highways Project Manager

Up to £45,700 p.a.
Broxbourne is going through an unprecedented period of place-making change. Cheshunt, Waltham Cross, Hertfordshire
Recruiter: Broxbourne Borough Council

Senior Engineer - Street Lighting/Furniture (Street Scene)

£41,346 - £46,392
Are you looking for an opportunity to work as an Engineer and make a difference within Hackney? Hackney, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Hackney London Borough Council

Transport and Highway Development Manager

£44,863 - £48,552
Are you passionate about delivering change that has a long-lasting, positive impact on people’s lives and where they live? Hove, East Sussex
Recruiter: Brighton & Hove City Council

Road Safety Officer - Take 5 Project

£25,419 - £32,798
The Road Safety team sits within the Transport Strategy and Network Management Service. Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Project Commissioning Assistant

£20,043 - £22,129
The city is leading an exciting period of regeneration so it’s an exciting time to be joining our team. Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of Bradford MDC

Strategic Waste Manager

£52,739 - £56,593
This is an exciting, rewarding and challenging role to work in the Environmental Commissioning team. Ellesmere Port, Cheshire
Recruiter: Cheshire West & Chester

Climate Change Manager

£41,591 - £43,570
NKDC has been committed to tackling climate change for over a decade. Sleaford, Lincolnshire
Recruiter: North Kesteven District Council

Senior Engineer

£36,853 to £47,784
We have an exciting opportunity for a Senior Engineer position within the Traffic and Engineering section. Richmond upon Thames, London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Civil Enforcement Officer (Blyth)

£22,571 - £24,919
You will be responsible for observing and enforcing parking controls in a fair and consistent manner. Blyth, Northumberland
Recruiter: Northumberland County Council

Capital Works Engineer

£32,427 to £41,361
We have an exciting opportunity for a Capital Works Engineer position within the Traffic and Engineering section. Richmond upon Thames, London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Highways Operative - Barrow x2

£22,571 – £23,454
We are looking to recruit a new Highways Operative to our Highways Service. Cumbria
Recruiter: Cumbria County Council

Flood Risk Engineer

£25,419
The Development Management Team is based in the Network Strategy Service area. North Yorkshire
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Contracting Assistant Engineer

£27,522 - £31,099 pay award pending
We are passionate about Doncaster - it’s a great place to live, do business and visit. Doncaster, South Yorkshire
Recruiter: Doncaster Council

Highways Presents

 

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video