MPs slam Govt on outsourcing and call for PFI halt

09/07/2018
Chris Ames

MPs have criticised the Government’s approach to outsourcing, accusing it of having a ‘preoccupation with cost’ while being unable to show it provides 'better services for less money'.

In a new report following the collapse fo Carillion, the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee called for a moratorium on new PFI schemes, and a review of the financing arrangements for two flagship roadbuilding schemes.

MPs said the Government's overriding priority for outsourcing is ‘spending as little money as possible while forcing contractors to take unacceptable levels of financial risk’.

Committee chair Sir Bernard Jenkin MP, said: ‘It is staggering that the Government has attempted to push risks that it does not understand onto contractors, and has so misunderstood its costs. It has accepted bids below what it costs to provide the service, so that the contract has had to be renegotiated.

‘The Carillion crisis itself was well-managed, but it could happen again unless lessons are learned about risk and contract management and the strengths and weaknesses of the sector.’

The committee said the Government’s approach was made more damaging by the fact that the information it uses to inform the outsourcing process can be ‘either incomplete or simply incorrect’, something it ‘must be aware’ of as it has written contracts that force contractors to pay out when it gets its own data wrong. 

The Government has also been known to forego performance penalties in the initial phases of contracts.

MPs said that ultimately, this has led to worse public services as companies have been sent a clear signal that cost, rather than quality of services, is the Government's consistent priority.

They said contractors had told them that the Government was known to prioritise cost over all other factors in procurements, ‘driving prices down to below the cost of the services they were asking firms to provide’.

‘Worse, the Government was unable to provide significant evidence for the basic assertion behind outsourcing: that it provides better services for less public money, or a rationale for why or how it decides to outsource a service. This was especially true for PFI. Shockingly, the Government admitted to the Committee that the "entire [PFI] structure is to keep the debt of the balance sheet”.’

The committee called on the Government to commit to underpinning contracts with realistic assessments of cost and risk transfer.

MPs also said that the Government ‘should not approve any further PFI projects until they can clearly justify, based on evidence, their claims about the benefits of the scheme’, adding: ‘Ministers should be able to choose to use state finance where it is clear that private finance would bring no benefits.'

The committee said: ‘The Treasury should scrutinise in particular the recently approved transport projects (the A303 Stonehenge tunnel and roads and the £1.5bn approach roads to the Lower Thames Crossing) to ensure that there is good evidence that private finance represents the best value for money in these cases.’

Highways has approached Highways England for comment.

Highways jobs

Team Leader - Highways

Milton Keynes Council
£50,941 - £54,228
Milton Keynes is a place of opportunity. Milton Keynes
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Highways Traffic Development Engineer

Milton Keynes Council
£34,788 - £38,813
Milton Keynes is a place of opportunity. Milton Keynes
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Assistant Contracts Engineer

Milton Keynes Council
£34,788 - £38,813
We are looking for an Assistants Contracts Engineer to be a key senior member of our Contracts Team managing... Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Team Leader - Streetworks

Milton Keynes Council
£39,782 - £43,662
We are looking for a Team Leader to lead our Streetworks Team. Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Traffic Project Officer

City of York Council
£26,875 to £29,783 per annum
City of York Council have a great opportunity for a Projects Officer to join our busy Traffic Team. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Traffic Management Leader

City of York Council
£35,500 to £40,710 per annum
City of York Council have an exciting opportunity for an experienced transport professional to lead our Traffic Team. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Senior Technician (Structures)

Milton Keynes Council
£29,636 - £33,779
With several future projects coming up this is an exciting time for an experienced Senior Technician to join our team.  Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Senior Engineer - Development Management

Milton Keynes Council
£44,632 - £49,298
We are looking for a Senior Engineer to work within our Development Management Team. Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Principal Transport Officer (Policy)

St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council
£38,813 To £40,760 per annum
This is an exciting opportunity for an energetic and motivated individual to drive forward transport policy to... St Helens, Merseyside
Recruiter: St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council

Road Safety Officer (Education and engagement)

Milton Keynes Council
£29,636 - £33,799
We are looking a Road Safety Officer to deliver our education and engagement programme across Milton Keynes. Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Road Safety Engineer

Milton Keynes Council
£34,788 - £38,813
We are looking for an experience Road Safety professional to join our team to process and analyse collision and casualty data and to... Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Development Management Engineer

Warwickshire County Council
£37,849 - £39,782 per annum
The successful applicant for this post will be capable of taking the lead on work within... Warwick, Warwickshire
Recruiter: Warwickshire County Council

Project Officers

Buckinghamshire Council
£29121 - £38881 per annum
OverviewCareer graded posts 5-7£29,121 - £38,881 per annumThis is your chance to make a lasting impact on our county. From developing the connected tr England, Buckinghamshire, Aylesbury
Recruiter: Buckinghamshire Council

Permit Coordinator

Milton Keynes Council
£29,636 - £33,799
We are looking for a Permit Coordinator to work within our Streetworks Team. Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Highways Liaison Officer

Milton Keynes Council
£29,636 - £33,799
We are looking for a Highways Liaison Officer to join our Communications and Liaison Team. Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

Clerk of Works

Milton Keynes Council
£29,636 - £33,779
We are looking for a Clerk of Works to join our expanding team, supporting the Senior Engineers to... Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire
Recruiter: Milton Keynes Council

CCTV Control Room Supervisor

Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
£24, 313 - £28, 785 pro rata
We are looking to recruit a supervisor to become part of the management team for our highly successful CCTV Control Room. Sandwell, West Midlands
Recruiter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Chair of the Board of Directors - Norwich City Services

Norwich City Council
£10,000 per annum
Join Norwich City Services Ltd and transform the way we look after our city and our people. Norwich, Norfolk
Recruiter: Norwich City Council

Team Leader

Buckinghamshire Council
Negotiable
OverviewThis is your chance to make a lasting impact on our county. From developing the connected transport networks of the future and driving sustain England, Buckinghamshire, Aylesbury
Recruiter: Buckinghamshire Council

Commercial Vehicle Technician

Chelmsford City Council
£30,000 per annum
We are seeking a fully trained HGV technician to work as part of the team who maintain the Council's fleet to the highest standards.  Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

 

ADEPT: Past and present

Highways England: Present and future

Mott MacDonald: Urban realm of the future

View the latest issue

Latest Video