Analysis: Fake news versus 'real futures'

Steve Birdsall

The robo-taxi, a self-driving vehicle whose passengers can watch television, drink champagne - or even sleep - is for many, a seductive vision. But Wes Lutz, chairman of the of the US National Automobile Dealers Association, is unimpressed.

'We have reached peak absurdity on this topic,' he told a press conference in Detroit earlier this month.

'We are not only living in exciting times...but in an era that rewards bold predictions more than gritty reality.'

Steve Birdsall, chief executive of Gaist

Mr Lutz, whose comments were reported by Bloomberg News, has a clear interest in talking down driverless technology in favour of car-ownership. But he is part of a growing body of people who are wearying of the daily claims about supposedly life-changing new technology – ranging from robo-cars to robot callers that will book your hair or doctor’s appointment - that surface in the media.

Many of us are questioning how much of the ‘ground-breaking’ technological news is real and how much is false? How many of these technologies have a real-world, practical use? In short - how much ‘fake tech-news’ is out there?

As the CEO of an innovation driven business, I know only too well the pressure that companies are under to stand out from the crowd - to demonstrate that they are ahead of the curve in developing exciting new products and services.

But increasingly I am conscious of the claims being made about new technology which do not stand up to even basic scrutiny.

Sure, companies should be allowed to promote what they are doing and give glimpses into the future. But companies who want ultimate success, must consider the ‘real-world’ application of their innovation - how the technology can be used, how it will fit into their customers’ way of working. Is it affordable? Will it offer a real return on investment?

Pothole hype

In highways asset management we hear all the time about new ‘intelligent sensors’ that are set to revolutionise the detection of road defects. When scrutinised, it is obvious that many are over-hyped and based on practically worthless technology which has no real application.

Take potholes. Over the last few years I have been dismayed by companies that are seeking to tap into’ the growing public dissatisfaction in local road condition. They claim that they have invented sensors fitted to cars and bicycles that can detect pot-holes and share the location of them to road users and network operators.

Some claim they can predict where and when potholes will form, before they are even visible to the human eye.

But anyone who has any expertise in road condition surveying and deterioration modelling will tell you that it takes an enormous amount of highly accurate, nuanced data to get anything close to detecting failure before it happens.

Gaist has been the technology supplier to the Department for Transport sponsored Pothole-spotter project and, for several years we have been developing systems that can handle the enormous amount of ‘near real-time’ data needed to understand the location and formation of potholes automatically.

We understand the challenges involved - the need to understand the extent, depth, whether it is a defective re-instatement or not and all the other risk factors that will lead to a decision to act on that information or not.

Other areas fraught with ‘over-hyping’ include:

Internet of what?

Not many people will have escaped the term ‘Internet of Things (IoT)’ which has been pushed heavily as heralding a breakthrough for transport infrastructure with eg. data from IoT sensors on streetlights helping transport agencies prioritise maintenance works.


Over the last few years I have been fortunate to travel the world on trade missions and have been amazed by the many providers of IoT platforms, but I have found only a limited number of credible ‘things’ to connect to these platforms.

This suggests to me that IoT platform providers are actually involved in a very crowded ‘land-grab’ in the vain hope that their platform will be the one that wins through at a time when the ‘things’ arrive.

This is a very risky strategy for companies and one which forces them to over-hype what they have to cut through the ‘chatter’ around this technology. The practical use for this technology is limited and heavily threatened at the moment by internet security issues. Without robust security systems we could put the entire transport system and public safety at risk.

Artificial Intelligence:

Companies and universities are heralding the arrival of Artificial Intelligence (AI) as the next big step change in technology – one that will revolutionise many aspects of work and home life.

I believe that in time it will. As a demonstration of that belief, Gaist is investing heavily into developing systems that are able to sift through vast amounts of data and make decisions that, until recently, only a human brain could cope with.

But these systems rely on vast amounts of highly accurate data and need extensive iterative training in controlled conditions to even start to get anything close to the capability of a human.

In the early days of our work around AI we did a lot of development and produced systems that couldn’t even compete with ‘tossing a coin’ as a decision-making system. I am pleased to say these systems are now much more accurate, but this has come with expensive investment into painstaking research and unimaginable volumes of data.

There are a lot of ambitious claims out there and there will be many more to come. Sadly, the law of the ‘marketing jungle’ dictates that companies must rush out press releases that make them look like leaders in technology and in doing so they are clouding the markets they wish to sell into.

Those individuals and organisation who are truly building ground breaking new technology that will change the world will be keeping it a secret….for now.

Highways jobs

Economic Infrastructure Manager

Essex County Council
Up to £57,000 per annum
It is an exciting time to be joining the Economic Growth team at Essex County Council Essex
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Principal Economic Growth Officer

Essex County Council
Up to £45,000 per annum
It is an exciting time to be joining the Economic Growth team at Essex County Council. Essex
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Plant and Vehicle Technician

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£24,799 - £26,317
Transport Services is responsible for all aspects of transport and related services including, procurement, maintenance and... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Road Safety Engineer

Cambridgeshire County Council
£21,589 - £31,371
Looking for a candidate who can participate in developing and delivering technically sound highway engineering solutions, to maintain and... Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Engineer - Assets

Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
£24,313 - £28,785 per annum
You will be a key part of the Highways Team responsible for assisting the Senior Engineer Assets... Sandwell, West Midlands
Recuriter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Environmental Protection Officer

London Borough of Sutton & The Royal Borough of Kingston Upon Thames
£25,809 to £33,291 (Grade F-G) / £33,291 to £42,684 (Grade H-I)
As an Environmental Protection Officer, you will be part of a small multidisciplinary team delivering a range of statutory environmental functions... Kingston Upon Thames (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Sutton & The Royal Borough of Kingston Upon Thames

Trading Standards Officer (Intellectual Property)

Camden London Borough Council
£36,630 - £42,490 per annum
Seeking to recruit two highly motivated and experienced Trading Standards Officer’s to join our busy Business and Consumer Services team. Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Principal Engineer-(Traffic)

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£42684 - £45585 per annum
Position Overview This is an exciting and varied role for an experienced Principal Engineer to join the Traffic Group and act as the lead officer on the Royal Borough of Greenwich's Traffic design, project delivery and traffic management of the borough England, London, Woolwich
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Service Manager - Transport Planning and Infrastructure  

Sheffield City Council
£48,458 - £53,244
Looking for someone with excellent communication, negotiation and analytical skills to work with key stakeholders across a range of disciplines to... Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Recuriter: Sheffield City Council

Parking Business Administrator Level 3 Apprenticeship

Brent Council
£15,000 p.a. inc
Loorking for someone keen to learn, you will demonstrate good communication skills, an understanding of good customer service... Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Head of Place

Hart District Council
Up to £75,000 with possibility of salary enhancement
New approaches and thinking. The same amazing district. Fleet, Hampshire
Recuriter: Hart District Council

Highway Inspector

East Riding of Yorkshire Council
An exciting new opportunity has arisen within our Highways Development Management team. Beverley, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: East Riding of Yorkshire Council

Transport Planning Officer X 2

Plymouth City Council
Grade E-F Grade E (£22,911 - £25,295) Grade F (£26,317 - £28,785) per annum
Seeking two enthusiastic and motivated individuals to join this dynamic team who wish to progress a career in the area of Transport Planning. Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Employment and Apprenticeship Officer

Brent Council
£33,291 - £35,724 p.a. inc.
Previous experience of successfully engaging employers and meeting their recruitment needs across a range of sectors is essential. Brent, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Student Environmental Health Officer Placements x 3 Jobs

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
National Living Wage plus enhancements for night time working
A unique chance to three Student Environmental Health Practitioners to gain experience of working within the Environmental Health function. Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Health and Safety Environmental Health Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£36,630 - £42,490 per annum
A fantastic opportunity has arisen for two highly motivated and experienced Environmental Health Officers to join our... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Transport Development Engineer

Bristol City Council
£22,021 - £23,836
An exciting opportunity has arisen in the Strategic Transport team for a junior engineer to join our Transport Development Management (TDM) team. Bristol (City Centre), City of Bristol
Recuriter: Bristol City Council

Transport Development Management Co-ordinator

Bristol City Council
£38,813 - £41,675
An exciting opportunity has arisen within Transport Development Management (TDM) City of Bristol
Recuriter: Bristol City Council

Contracts Manager - Core Service

Liverpool City Council
£37,849 - £42,683 per year
The successful candidate will manage and maintain Highways partnerships and contractual arrangements to ensure effective, quality and value for... Liverpool, Merseyside
Recuriter: Liverpool City Council

Transport Inspectors – Land & Maritime Security

Department for Transport
£33,990 - £36,880
Looking for Transport Security Inspectors to join our team to focus on direct monitoring and assessing of industry compliance against... London (Greater)
Recuriter: Department for Transport

Download your Highways App

Google App Apple App

Highways on Fridays

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Exclusion by numbers

Cold Comfort review

Roadworks, what roadworks?

View the latest issue

Latest Video