Rare 10-year study shows benefits of apshalt reinforcement

10/11/2020
Richard Carr

Richard Carr of ABG - a leader in high performance geosynthetic systems -  discusses a 10-year trial showing geosynthetic asphalt reinforcement can save on maintenance costs.

More than just a bump in the road

Increasing traffic volumes, heavier loadings and the frequency of flooding events all place an excessive strain on the UK’s road infrastructure, resulting in defects from reflective cracking and potholes.

Asphalt Industry Alliance (AIA) put an astronomical price tag of almost £11bn to repair every pothole in England and Wales.

Highway repairs in England cost anywhere between £6,500 to £120,000 per mile depending on the extent of the damage, making more cost-effective, long-term fixes to road renovations paramount.

Why reinforce asphalt?

In civil engineering, the principle of adding a tensile element into a weaker material to make it stronger is well established, with the most obvious example being steel reinforced concrete.

Asphalt reinforcement utilises the same principle, low strain elements absorbing load pressures, reducing movement and preventing the development of cracks.

Many laboratory tests and anecdotal evidence show reinforced pavements last significantly longer, or can be constructed at a reduced thickness to achieve the same design life. However, it has always been very hard to prove on an actual heavily trafficked road due to accessibility issues and the difficulty of monitoring, plus the ad hoc maintenance by utility companies obscuring results, especially over a long period such as 10 years.

Normally councils do not have the resources or budget to continually monitor a road over that time period.

Meltham Mills road trial of long-term reinforcement

An ideal opportunity arose in 2009 when Meltham Mills Road, which acts as a bypass to the town of Meltham in West Yorkshire, needed to be fully resurfaced.

A machine installing the geosynthetic system

The road happens to run alongside an estate of industrial units serving a number of factories including ABG Geosynthetics Ltd.

ABG approached Kirklees Council with a proposed trial of their asphalt reinforcement material placed along a proportion of the road, including across the entrance to their factory where the heaviest traffic occurred.

The whole of Meltham Mills Road was planed 100mm and the trial area of geosynthetic installed and overlain with a binder and surface course.

Typical asphalt reinforcement installation build up

Monitoring of the site was easy since the firm’s engineers walk along the road each workday to access the site entrance and could note any changes in condition over the whole 10-year period.

A time lapse camera was fixed to the wall of the entrance to the ABG factory to record vehicle movements throughout the day and night to give a record of the type and frequency of traffic along Meltham Mills Road.

This gave the opportunity to record a vehicle movement count and intensity, with peak flows reaching eight vehicle movements per minute. In addition to the car and van movements, there were 189 HGV vehicle movements per day. This is three times the average traffic for a minor urban road in the Yorkshire region. The entrance to ABG factory saw vehicles turning and manoeuvring, placing high stress on this area.

SCANNER Survey

After 10 years of heavy trafficking the surface showed distinct signs of distress in the non-reinforced areas. SCANNER (Surface Condition Assessment of the National Network of Roads) results from Kirklees Council provided a dataset of road surface cracking for the longitudinal profile of the road for each lane.

The reinforcement installation area (blue) and highly trafficked area (pink) show a correlation with SCANNER results. There are obvious deformations in the unreinforced and heavily trafficked zone (pink) but no notable defects in the heavily trafficked reinforced zone (blue/pink stripes). See figure 1 below.

Figure 1 – SCANNER crack survey mapped to geosynthetic installation. The heavily trafficked/ reinforced sections (blue and pink stripes) show no sign of cracking, whereas adjacent to this heavy cracking occurs.

The benefit of geosynthetic asphalt reinforcement

After the 10 year period Kirklees agreed that the trial had been a success, providing the much needed evidence that asphalt reinforcement extends the life of a road. Kirklees had used similar treatments on other roads in the borough, which, while not monitored as closely, showed the same increase in performance.

Graham Mallory, who was the group engineer, highways and operations at Kirklees Council at the time of the trial, said: 'The trial enabled evidence and comparison of road surface performance at a single site with and without the use of the reinforcement layer.

'As a consequence of using the reinforcement layer we can clearly see the effectiveness in reducing reflective cracking, a longer service life, reduced reactive maintenance works, financial savings over time, and reduced disruption to businesses and the travelling public.'

Based on this long term study it is clear that asphalt reinforcement can provide a significant cost benefit. The initial £5 per m2 cost to install the geosynthetic is recouped by year six owing to the reduction in maintenance required. Comparing a 22-year lifecycle for an unreinforced maintained road with a 26-year lifecycle, the reinforced road saves 21% in maintenance costs alone and it is estimated the overall cost savings will be over 50%.

Long-term asphalt reinforcement trial key findings

  • Unique 10 year repair monitoring period
  • Busy road with high HGV loadings servicing local industrial estate. Three times the average traffic volume for a minor road in West Yorkshire
  • SCANNER results show crack formation correlation between reinforced and unreinforced sections
  • Maintenance saving of 21% and total cost saving of 50% extrapolated over 26-year road life
  • Proven by SCANNER graph, no cracks within geosynthetic reinforced area
  • Reduction in CO2 emissions owing to extended maintenance and resurfacing cycles

You can find out more about asphalt reinforcement geosynthetics at an upcoming seminar from LCRIG

Highways jobs

Travel Training Service Support Officer

£18029 - £19329 per annum
Please note this is a fixed term contract for 12 months, starting in January. The role is part time for 22.2 hours (3 days) per week. Therefore the England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Engineer HDC/S38

Competitive Salary
We are looking for an enthusiastic, committed, and experienced highway engineer to join our successful Highways team. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

South London Waste Partnership (SLWP) Director

£96,192 - £108,213 per annum
This is a highly visible, senior role, working with local government chief officers as well as sub-regional and regional organisations.  London (Greater)
Recruiter: South London Waste Partnership

Grounds Maintenance Operative

£19,312 - £20,493 per annum
This position is Seasonal/Fixed Term from 22 March to 29 October 2021. Sandwell, West Midlands
Recruiter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Head of Highways

£53,984 - £63,449
You will have a proven track record of success in delivering effective highway services and substantial capital programmes as... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Vehicle Technician x2

£24,982 - £29,577 per annum
These positions are fixed term contracts for 12 months with the prospect of a permanent role once the Class C Driving Licence has been obtained.  Sandwell, West Midlands
Recruiter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Commercial Vehicle Technician

£30,000 per annum
We are seeking a fully trained HGV technician to work as part of the team who maintain the Council's fleet to the highest standards.  Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Clerk of Works

£32,234 - £35,745
We are looking for someone who... Warrington, Cheshire
Recruiter: Warrington Borough Council

Executive Director of Place, Economy & Environment – West Northamptonshire Council

Up to £140k
Be part of shaping the future Northamptonshire
Recruiter: North Northamptonshire & West Northamptonshire

Director Public Protection and Licensing

circa £123k
At Westminster, we are passionate about the place and the people who live, work and visit here. City of Westminster, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Westminster City Council

Senior Data Centre Engineer

£41,952
The successful candidate will have a BSc in relevant discipline, or equivalent industry experience. Camden, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Camden London Borough Council

Lead Network Engineer

£46,756
We are going through exciting new changes, which require the need for Lead Network engineers who can redesign, architect, document and... Camden, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Camden London Borough Council

Community Protection Regulatory Officer

£26,112 per annum, rising to £28,785
The successful applicant will provide support to the team’s Environmental Health Officers while also benefitting from their experience and guidance. Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Grounds Maintenance Supervisor

£26,112 per annum, rising to £28,785
The successful candidate will show enthusiasm and a commitment to effectively deliver excellent service to... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Drainage Engineer & Senior Drainage Engineer

£32,234 - £35,745 (Engineer), £35,745 - £39,880 (Senior Engineer)
Lincolnshire County Council has exciting opportunities for a Drainage Engineer (x1) and Senior Drainage Engineer Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Principal S106 & CIL Officer (Infrastructure Planning)

£43,860 - £46,839 p.a. inc.
To be successful in this role, you will bring strong S106 & CIL collection experience, be able to... Wembley, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Brent Council

Head of Built Environment

£67,036 - £76,613 per annum
The post holder will deliver the effective strategic improvement, co-ordination and management of the planned... Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of Bradford MDC

Highways Maintenance Engineer

£30,492 - £32,851
We are looking to recruit a suitably qualified and experienced Highway Maintenance Engineer to join our Key Projects Team at... Worcestershire
Recruiter: Worcestershire County Council

Street Cleaning Operatives / Drivers

£21,795 - £22,995 Per Annum
We are looking for hard working, motivated, reliable people to join our team. Barnet (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recruiter: Barnet London Borough Council

Senior Infrastructure Design Engineer

£35,745 - £38,890 per annum
Do you want to work in an innovative, positive team that shapes and develops the places we live and work in? Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Highways Presents

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Also inside:

Big Interview: IHE President Stephen Webb

ADEPT Traffic Managers' Conference

Legal: JV or not JV?

View the latest issue

Latest Video