London joint venture loses High Court battle with TfL

19/04/2018
Dominic Browne

A joint venture working under the London Highways Alliance Contract (LoHAC) has lost a High Court battle with Transport for London (TfL) over work rates.

Colas, VolkerHighways and AECOM (CVU) disagreed with TfL over payment rates in conjunction with the capital's permit scheme, which imposes charges for working on roads during peak hours.

The joint venture argued that strict working time constraints placed on it by TfL's highways permit scheme delayed and prolonged work, requiring extra shifts and added costs.

CVU said it had understood there would be a window for night-time noisy works between 7.30pm and midnight but in practice this was severely curtailed by permit conditions.

CVU argued that it was therefore entitled to claim for the cost impacts of the restriction with revised rates and prices. TfL maintained that agreed rates and uplifts in the existing deal covered all limitations or restrictions on working conditions.

Justice O’Farrell said: 'CVU makes a valid point that the framework agreement does not contain definitive hours and other conditions in which the works under task orders must be carried out.

'That introduces uncertainty as to the duration, scope and cost of work required. Any requirement by CVU to price such uncertainties would result in uncommercial high rates. There is a risk that contractors could include a premium for the risk of uncertain restrictions on working if forced to price them at the outset.'

The judge added: 'However, that is balanced by the competitive tendering that applied for the framework agreement, and the volume and spread of works, from those at high risk of imposed restrictions to those at low risk of imposed restrictions. The inbuilt uncertainty introduced risk for both parties that could be assessed and evaluated.

'The purpose for which the schedule of rates was required was to provide consistency and certainty in the pricing of the works. The use of a schedule of rates enabled TfL to evaluate the tenders on a fair and equal basis. The fixing of rates and prices for the framework agreement provides opportunity and risk for both parties.

'If CVU undertakes the work instructed in a shorter duration or at lower cost than anticipated, it will receive a "windfall" and TfL will have "overpaid". If CVU incurs greater costs than anticipated, it will have to bear the loss and TfL will have made a saving.

'It was a matter for each party to assess the risks associated with permits issued and to price those risks accordingly.'

CVU is in talks with TfL about removing itself from core work under the LoHAC framework; however this relates to cut backs in Transport for London's roads spend and has nothing to do with this court case.

A spokeswoman for CVU said: 'CVU would like to reiterate that they are in discussions with TfL to consider stepping down from core work in the central London area. This action was agreed prior to the result of the recent court case being announced, and is in response to the removal of the government operating subsidy.'

Highways jobs

Engineer (Highways Scheme Design)

Medway Council
£31,888 - £37,646 per annum
The post-holder will be required to have highway engineering expertise in order to contribute to efficient and effective provision of... Medway City Estate, Rochester
Recruiter: Medway Council

Principal Flood Risk Officer

Lancashire County Council
£42,683-£46,566
We have an exciting opportunity for a Principal Floor Risk Officer Lancashire
Recruiter: Lancashire County Council

Resources and Waste Commercial and Contracts Manager

Northumberland County Council
£47,107 - £50,394
We are looking for a strategic, innovative and performance-focused leader to join us as Resources and Waste; Commercial and Contracts Manager. County Hall, Morpeth, Northumberland
Recruiter: Northumberland County Council

SEN Travel Assessment Co-ordination Officer

London Borough of Bexley
£35,529 - £41,796
We are currently seeking an experienced officer administrator who will enjoy working as team and under their own initiative, with duties including... Bexleyheath, London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Bexley

Principal Planning Liaison Officer X3

Somerset County Council
£33,799 to £37,849 per annum
We have a number of fantastic opportunities in Somerset at various levels Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Principal Estate Roads Engineer

Somerset County Council
£33,799 to £37,849 per annum
We have a number of fantastic opportunities in Somerset at various levels Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Principal Travel Plan Officer

Somerset County Council
£33,799 to £37,849 per annum
We have a number of fantastic opportunities in Somerset at various levels Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Assistant Estate Roads Engineer x2

Somerset County Council
£25,295 to £28,785 per annum
We have 2 exciting opportunities for enthusiastic and committed individuals to join our Highways Development Management Team Taunton, Somerset
Recruiter: Somerset County Council

Highways Infrastructure and Maintenance Manager

Bridgend County Borough Council
£38,813 - £40,760 per annum
An exciting opportunity has arrived inside the Highway Asset Maintenance Team within the Communities Directorate. Bridgend (Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr)
Recruiter: Bridgend County Borough Council

Design Services Manager

Lincolnshire County Council
£50,430 - £55,503
We are a team of mixed experience and skills, proud to serve the people of Lincolnshire and have fun whilst doing so! Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Transport Planning Officer

North Yorkshire County Council
£29,636 to £32,029
We are looking for a Transport Planning Officer to join our Highways and Transportation service. Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Transforming Cities Fund - Project Delivery Manager

North Yorkshire County Council
£48,000 to £55,840
We are looking to appoint to the pivotal position of TCF Project Delivery Manager on a 3 year fixed-term contract, to... Northallerton, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Funeral Operative (Part Time)

Brent Council
£24,462 - £26,274 (pro-rata) p.a. inc.
The person will not need previous experience in funeral services as full training will be given but experience would be an advantage. Wembley, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Brent Council

Field Officer

Northumberland County Council
£21,589 - £23,836
Field Officer, Permanent,  37 hours per week.  Closing date 29 May 2020 at midnight  Plessey Woods Country Park
Recruiter: Northumberland County Council

Solicitor - Planning & Transportation Team

Birmingham City Council
£34,788 - £42,683
This is an opportunity to join a team of specialist lawyers dedicated to the Council achieving... Birmingham, West Midlands
Recruiter: Birmingham City Council

Application Support Analyst

Redbridge London Borough Council
£34,794.00 - £36,711.00
Looking for an experienced Application Support Analyst to join our IT & Digital Services team.  Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Engineer (Drainage)

Medway Council
£31,888 - £37,646 per annum
The post holder will be expected to work closely with our term maintenance contractor to successfully complete schemes. Medway City Estate, Rochester
Recruiter: Medway Council

Refuse Drivers - Rolling Advert, applications checked weekly

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£22.377 - £23.607
It is an exciting time in Waste and Street Services at the Royal Borough of Greenwich. Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Car Parks and Neighbourhoods Manager

Derbyshire Dales District Council
£36,876 - £39,782 per annum
An exciting opportunity has arisen to lead and develop the Derbyshire Dales District Council’s Neighbourhoods team. Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire Dales District Council

Community and Environmental Support Officer – 10 Jobs

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£19,554 - £21,166
You will be doing light maintenance work including removal of graffiti, dealing with overhanging vegetation and removal of... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Crossing the inflection point

COVID-19 recovery plans revealed

Modelling a changing world

The great reallocation

View the latest issue

Latest Video