Lugg review: Packaging may make repairs unaffordable

17/07/2023 | RHODRI CLARK

A common approach to renewals or repairs along Welsh trunk road corridors that sees works packaged together could delay work to address the principal asset risk if the package cannot be funded, a review of maintenance on the Welsh strategic road network (SRN) has argued.

The Welsh Government has published and accepted all 15 recommendations the Lugg review, the final report of a team of experts under former CIHT president Matthew Lugg that it set up in 2021 to consider whether current SRN maintenance programmes were cost effective in discharging ministers’ duties on safety and serviceability.

The team’s work had previously fed into the review of Welsh roads policy, completed last year by a panel led by Lynn Sloman.

Wales’ new SRN Asset Management Programme will take account of each route’s function or character and not assume that infrastructure must be renewed like for like; in some places speed limits could be changed or road space reallocated to active travel.

The Welsh SRN has a £1bn maintenance backlog. Most Major Asset Renewal (MAR) schemes are relatively small, but large structures in urgent need of repair include the M4 Malpas viaduct in Newport, the twin A48 Briton Ferry viaducts near Neath (below) and the M4 Tawe bridge near Swansea.

These three schemes are costed at £225m but the structures work accounts for only £155m of the total, the Lugg Review notes.

It observes that officials from the Welsh Government and their agents have investigated ‘significant complementary works’ in the schemes. ‘The rationale … would be to take advantage of the traffic management needed for the primary works, and so reduce outturn costs.’

The report comments that while the corridor approach may generate potential whole-life benefits, it will ‘undoubtably lead to high and potentially unsustainable investment levels being needed’. It warns that aggregating schemes ‘will undoubtedly lead to significant levels of investment being required which could be undeliverable in the present funding circumstances’. This could lead to ‘a reluctance to begin to develop the designs for the works required to rectify the principal issue’.

The review found that the MAR took a ‘top-down’ view of the network while 42 other SRN maintenance programmes were ‘bottom-up’ collections of schemes. It comments: ‘Consideration of the programme elements put forward by asset managers should recognise the potential for them to be influenced by the desire to retain budgets and workload for their areas of responsibility.’

The review found further inconsistency within the MAR, with structures elements being based on the Structures Asset Valuation and Investment Tool and non-structures corridor renewal works having been generated without ‘the same level of rigour’. Instead, processes and judgements should be detailed, to provide transparency and enable the government to demonstrate rigour or compliance (including if a road is alleged to be out of repair under Section 56 of the Highways Act 1980).

The report recommends a zero-based review of all maintenance schemes, using an auditable Red Amber Green process across multiple programmes which takes into account the sources of risk, probability of failure and potential consequences. A do-minimum list of renewals and repairs –work needed to meet the Government’s statutory duty – should be created, with designs progressed to ‘shovel ready’.

Maintenance programmes should also recognise the priorities laid down in the Welsh Transport Strategy (WTS), including minimising whole-life carbon emissions and improving resilience to climate change. A set of investment criteria for maintenance should be created, similar to that adopted by the government for new roads following the Sloman review.

The Lugg review says that, subject to these recommendations, all current safety critical programmes should continue. ‘Particular attention should be paid to Major Asset Renewal and the Tunnel Programme which the review team consider [are] the areas [where] Welsh ministers are exposed to the greatest risk.’

The review’s report adds that maintenance can help drive the increase in sustainable transport usage set out in the WTS. Inspections and repairs should take account of the government’s intended usage of a highway alongside its current usage.

‘By way of example, transport policy seeks to encourage cycling as a sustainable transport mode,’ says the report. ‘If cyclists are presented with a highway that is in a hazardous condition for them but one that presents no significant risk to cars, cycling will be discouraged (indeed cyclists may well be harmed).’

Highways InProfile

latest magazine issue
Highways jobs

Street Lighting Project Engineer

PO2 - £41,442 to £44,331
Help us keep our streets safe, efficient and ready for the future Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Principal Engineer - Highways Development Management

£47,181.00 - £50,269.00, Grade 11, 37 hours, Permanent
We are seeking a dedicated Principal Highways Development Management Engineer to join our team. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Highways Development Management Engineer

£32,061.00 - £46,142.00, Career Grade 7-10, 37 hours, Permanent
Do you want to join a team helping to shape the future of Wakefield through HIghways Development Management? Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Highways Project Engineer

£31,537 - £42,839 per annum
Would you like to be part of our friendly, welcoming Highways team, proud to manage all aspects of the highway network? Boroughbridge, York
Recruiter: North Yorkshire Council

Highways Project Engineer

£31,537 - £42,839 per annum
Would you like to be part of our friendly, welcoming Highways team, proud to manage all aspects of the highway network? Skipton, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: North Yorkshire Council

Technician - Highway Inspector

Grade 8 £29,719 - £31,691 per annum
Within the Highways Maintenance Team we are looking for an enthusiastic, customer focused and experienced person Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Highway Design and Construction Manager

Grade N, scp50 £62,443 to scp53 £65,663 per annum, plus essential car user allowance
We embrace AI to enhance our operations and to innovate our services. Bolton, Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Bolton Council

Technician - Highway Inspector

Grade 8 £29,719 - £31,691 per annum
At Derbyshire, we have been on a journey to transform the way we deliver highway services. Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Team Leader (Maintenance Operations)

Grade 10 - £48,226 - £51,356
Cardiff is growing faster than any other capital city in Europe. Cardiff (Caerdydd)
Recruiter: Cardiff Council

Highways Supervisor

£Competitive
We have a fantastic opportunity for a permanent Highways Supervisor Forfar, Angus
Recruiter: Amey

Tree Surveyor

£Competitive
We are excited to offer fantastic opportunities for Permanent Tree Surveyors Scotland
Recruiter: Amey

Chief Operating Officer – South West Wales Corporate Joint Committee

£Competitive
We’re looking for a bold, visionary leader to take on the role of Chief Operating Officer Carmarthenshire (Sir Gaerfyrddin)
Recruiter: Carmarthenshire County Council

Clerk of Works - Highways

£Competitive
We have a fantastic opportunity for a Clerk of Works to join our dynamic NMC SW Account team at Polmadie. Glasgow, Glasgow City
Recruiter: Amey

Highways Supervisor

£Competitive
We have a fantastic opportunity for a permanent Highways Supervisor to join our NMC NE account in Kinross. Perth and Kinross
Recruiter: Amey

Planner - Highways

£Competitive
We have a fantastic opportunity for Permanent Planner – Highways to join our NMC SW Account. Glasgow City
Recruiter: Amey

Highways Maintenance Manager

£51,356 - £55,539 per annum
We are looking for an experienced Engineer to join the team as a Highways Maintenance Manager Selby, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: North Yorkshire Council

Highways Maintenance Manager

£51,356- £55,539 per annum
We are looking for an experienced Engineer to join the team as a Highways Maintenance Manager Brompton on Swale, Richmond
Recruiter: North Yorkshire Council

Permit Officer - Internal works promoter - WMF2244e

£34,434 - £35,412
The streetworks Permit Officer role within the highways service Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Highways Development Management Engineer

£41,816 - £45,175
You will be based in the Highways Development Team and work closely with colleagues across the wider transport service. Northamptonshire
Recruiter: West Northamptonshire Council

Transport Project Officer

£34,203 - £37,067
We are seeking an enthusiastic and motivated project officer to work in our Highways and Transport Service. Northamptonshire
Recruiter: West Northamptonshire Council
SUBSCRIBE NOW

Latest Video

Subscribe to Highways today to ensure you keep your finger on the pulse of everything happening in the UK road network throughout the year.

SUBSCRIBE NOW