National Highways' railway structures strategy ‘unravelling'

09/02/2023
Chris Ames

National Highways' strategy of using emergency powers to infill historic railway structures is ‘unravelling’, campaigners have said, after a third council told it to seek planning permission, without which it may have to remove the infill.

The government-owned company manages 3,100 structures within the Historic Railways Estate (HRE) on behalf of the Department for Transport.

It has been criticised by campaigners for its approach to managing structures which has often involved infill works, sometimes blocking routes that could be used for active travel.

It has now admitted that it assumed that work carried out on a bridge in Norfolk ‘to prevent an emergency’ arising could remain permanently without planning permission.

In fact, the rules around ‘permitted development’ make clear that any works carried out under what is known as Class Q must be removed after 12 months, unless the local planning authority agrees otherwise.

National Highways has also said that its assessment that infilling was the most cost-effective solution was based on an assumption that it would remain permanently.

The company has already been given a deadline of October to remove 1,600 tonnes of infill from a bridge at Great Musgrave, Cumbria after Eden District Council rejected a planning application for its retention.

In addition, Selby District Council is expecting the submission of a retrospective planning application this week relating to the infilling of a structure near Tadcaster.

Both schemes were carried out under Class Q ‘permitted development’ rights.

King’s Lynn and West Norfolk Borough Council has now told National Highways that it is in breach of planning rules in relation to infill works at Congham bridge (pictured) as 12 months have passed and the land has not been restored to its original condition.

The works are regarded as ‘unauthorised’ and the company has been asked to apply for planning permission.

In October 2019, National Highways’ consultants, Jacobs, told the council that Congham bridge represented ‘an ongoing and increasing risk to public safety’ and was proposed for infilling under permitted development rights.

The works began in March 2021 and were completed the following month.

The head of the HRE programme, Hélène Rossiter, said: ‘Before carrying out the work we consulted with both of the relevant local planning authorities, which confirmed they had no objections or comments relating to the schemes.

‘We infilled Congham Road Bridge in February 2021 because we viewed it as a public safety risk.’

Asked by Highways what its intention was regarding planning permission when infilling was carried out, a National Highways spokesperson said: ‘Our intention was to retain the work permanently. We sought to rely on our Permitted Development rights under Class Q, which allows the retention of such work without the need to apply for planning permission.

‘We had written to the council advising them of the work being undertaken and received no objections. This was interpreted as approval by the council, and that we could retain the infill under our Permitted Development rights.’

National Highways was also asked whether it took into account the fact that Class Q development rights only last 12 months when it assessed that infilling was the most cost-effective option.

A spokesperson said that as the council did not object to the permanent infilling of the bridge National Highways had assumed that it would remain permanently.

The spokesperson added that for the same reason, National Highways had not calculated the costs of removing the infill and adopting an alternative solution.

The spokesperson added: ‘In conclusion, based on the information we had at the time, we determined that infilling was cost effective, expedient and in the public interest. A position that we still stand by today.’

Graeme Bickerdike - from the HRE Group, which campaigns on the issue - said that National Highways had used the same permitted development rights to infill at least six structures with three local authorities asking for retrospective planning applications and another having ‘vigorously opposed the work from the outset’.

In many cases, councils had pushed back because no evidence was provided to support the claims and most of the affected structures have since disappeared from the company’s works programme without any interventions, HRE said.

Mr Bickerdike added: ‘The strategy was intended to avoid the difficulties that come with public scrutiny, but that’s clearly unravelling. These rights were never appropriate for permanent works to structures that were fundamentally fine. Permitted development empowered National Highways to impose its preferred method of managing these assets.’

A National Highways spokesperson told Highways: ‘We refute in the strongest terms any insinuation that there were willing breaches of statutory obligations.’

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

ALSO INSIDE:

  • RoadExpo Scotland Preview
  • Legal brief: How to be a net zero hero
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Assistant Lighting Engineer

£35,745 - £36,648
This role is a great opportunity for candidates who have significant experience of lighting and construction. Barrow in Furness, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Plant Mechanic

£16,066 - £19,072
To provide a high quality, comprehensive and efficient maintenance, inspection, repair and test service. Mansfield, Nottinghamshire
Recruiter: Mansfield District Council

Technical Assistant - Traffic Management

£28,770 - £33,024 GBP year
Are you looking for a career in highways? Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Streetworks Technical Assistant

£28,770 - £33,024 GBP year
Liverpool City Council has embarked on a major improvement programme that involves all parts of the organisation. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Senior Transport Planner

£38,223 - £43,421 GBP year
Liverpool City Council has two exciting opportunities for Senior Transport Planners. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Senior Engineer Traffic Orders

£38,223 - £43,421 GBP year
Liverpool City Council has embarked on a major improvement programme that involves all parts of the organisation. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Public Transport Policy Lead

£38,223 - £43,421 GBP year
Do you want to improve public transport for the City of Liverpool. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

Senior Engineer - Planned Maintenance

£38,223 - £43,421 GBP year
We are looking for a Senior Engineer to manage our planned maintenance programme. Liverpool, Merseyside
Recruiter: Liverpool City Council

X2 Civil Enforcement Officer

£26,421 - £27,334
Are you looking for a role where you can work independently and with a great team of people? Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Highway Technician

£29,269 - £31,364
Highway and Transport Services – Enhancing Lives, Building Communities Wiltshire
Recruiter: Wiltshire Council

EV Infrastructure Delivery Officer

£32,076 - £33,945
Sustainable Transport – Decarbonising the Future Wiltshire
Recruiter: Wiltshire Council

Street Cleansing Driver / Operative (Pavement Sweeper)

£24,294 - £25,979, Grade 5, 37 hours, Permanent
The post holder will be part of a Street Scene Team to deliver a high quality citizen focused Street Scene service Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Street Cleansing Operative

£24,294 - £25,979 Grade 5, 37 hours, Permanent
An opportunity exists in the Council’s Street Scene Services for a Street Cleansing Operative Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Assistant Highway Maintenance Engineer – Operations (Career Grade)

£23,500 - £39,186 pro rata, Grade 4 to 9, 37 hours, Permanent
We are looking for two assistant engineers to be part of our Highways Network Management Team. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Principal Transport Planning Officer

£42,403 - £45,441
We have an exciting opportunity for an experienced professional to join our team in Hull. Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recruiter: Hull City Council

Highway Project Engineer (Operations)

£40,221 - £43,421, Grade 10, 37 hours, Permanent
We are looking for an experienced Project Engineer to be part of our Highways Network Management Team. Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Neighbourhood Officer Level 1 Arbor Inspector - 1798

Grade 6 £28,900 - £32,020
The Arboricultural Department in Manchester has a key role to play in making Manchester a greener city. Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Manchester City Council

Site Supervisor / Liaison Officer - SIA Qualified

£22361 - £24309 per annum + + 26 Days Leave & Defined Benefit Pension
Site Supervisor / Liaison Officer - SIA QualifiedPermanent, Full TimeUp to £24,309 per annumLocation
Recruiter: Essex County Council

EV Infrastructure Project Officer

£40,221 - £42,403
We are in the process of developing an Electric Vehicle Strategy for Wiltshire Wiltshire / Trowbridge
Recruiter: Wiltshire Council

Technical Support Officer - Enforcement

£24,948 - £26,845
Highway and Transport Services – Enhancing Lives, Building Communities Wiltshire / Devizes
Recruiter: Wiltshire Council

Highways Presents

 


Latest Video