Q and A with Mathew Lugg: Self-assessment, self-assessed

Dominic Browne

The Department for Transport’s Incentive Fund self-assessment process came on the scene five years ago and has undergone changing fortunes and differing levels of support ever since. As it comes to the end of its first funding cycle this financial year, and looks set for reform, Dominic Browne speaks to one of its creators about a funding pot that punched above its weight but sometimes lost its balance

A top sliced cash pot is not really supposed to change a sector. It’s a politician’s gift, a press release, a civil servant’s pet project. In highways it often just shores up finance that had bled off into other services anyway. The highways self-assessment process was different.

With a relatively small amount of cash, this funding system accelerated and locked in a culture change that helped staunch the wounds of austerity.

If we had to face up to managed decline, at least it had to be managed well. The sector knew ‘worst first’ was not the way to go, but was not always as quick as it should have been in introducing highways asset management plans.

The self-assessment process took the matter out of officers' hands, then told them to stop the hand wringing and get on with it.   

From resistance to acceptance, to celebration and then to scepticism, the sector has changed its mind several times about the self-assessment concept, which emerged out of the now disbanded Highways Maintenance Efficiency Programme.

It was intended to do away with perverse incentives for poor performance and introduce a real financial incentive around asset management.

While highway authorities recoiled at first at the idea of cash strapped councils losing even more money during some of the hardest cuts to local finance ever seen, eventually hard-nosed engineers recognised that it helped them raise standards, not least in securing more cash from politicians.

Then the suspicions began to creep in. Was everyone in Band 3 really a top performing council? Weren’t some places being a bit over generous. When former director of local transport Graham Pendlebury admitted the DfT could not afford to carry out official audits of the returns it seemed the issue was out in the open. 

Highways understands some form of voluntary audit group has been in development but such are the practical barriers involved, it has remained in development.

The mixed emotions about the scheme can be summed up in two responses from senior figures in the sector.

One said: ‘Self-assessment has been really good. It has made people think about it. It’s enabled people to get the resources both people and money to actually make the asset management more efficient. The self-assessment has brought asset management on without a doubt.' 

Another said: ‘There are authorities that say they are Band 3 and can’t back it up with evidence. They are not doing the things they claim and the DfT do nothing with it. They just sign it off.’

Q and A with Matthew Lugg

Matthew Lugg OBE, is head of profession at WSP Local Government. He was on secondment at the DfT just over five years ago and helped write the questionnaire the process was based on.

How did it come about and what impact do you think the self-assessment process has had?

‘The view from HMEP was that despite all the development of all HMEP products there still many local highway authorities that had made limited progress in all the attributes that can drive efficiencies and service improvement, namely asset management, customer engagement, resilience, benchmarking and service improvement, and better procurement.

‘In discussion with DfT, HMEP felt if some of the capital maintenance funding could be incentivised to encourage local highway authorities take on board these attributes then it was more likely that this would happen.

‘I remember at the time there was a lot of opposition but if you ask any senior local authority highway managers now they are very complimentary about the difference that self-assessment has made particularly in achieving political support for better asset management.’  

Have there been any changes to the questions over the years?

No -  it has stood the test of time and it was always felt it would be unfair to move the goalposts part the way through its five-year duration.

What concerns do you have about the lack of audit for the responses?

The whole process lost a lot of credibility at an early stage when all those highway authorities that formed part of combined authorities were excluded from the incentivisation process. This included all the Manchester, Liverpool, Teesside, West Midlands and Bristol Mets probably around 30 councils many of whom were the ones that most needed to improvement.

DfT have been threatening some form of audit for a while which I offered to help them with as inevitably when large sums of Government may be lost as a consequence of not getting into a particular band the local highway authorities will try push the boundaries to protect their budgets.

Do you think the process should have been done any differently looking back?

No, I think it served its purpose as most local highway authorities have achieved Band 3 status and it now needs to be revamped. 

How do you think it should change in the future?

My advice is that before agreeing to provide any additional capital maintenance funding following the spring budget or the comprehensive spending review, DfT should require local authorities to demonstrate what outcomes they will achieve as a consequence.

So unlike the self-assessment process, which relied on evidence of systems and process this new approach will require evidence of achieving tangible outcomes to the highway infrastructure. This also may require some external stewardship.

Will there ever be a future body/new version of HMEP, do you think?

No, not as such. There are lots of proactive regional groups of local highway authorities doing valuable collaborative work it just perhaps lacks some national overview which could be through UKRLG.

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue


Highways Awards 2021 finalists revealed

Harris leads National Highways into new era

View the latest issue

Highways jobs

Traffic Engineering Specialist

£31,272 per annum (Band 6)
Eastleigh Borough Council is an ambitious and progressive council with a good reputation for tackling environmental issues. Eastleigh, Hampshire
Recruiter: Eastleigh Borough Council

Commissioning Officer - Highways Asset Management

£34,728 - £36,922 per annum
We are looking to appoint a Highways Asset Management Officer to join our successful and innovative team. Warwick, Warwickshire
Recruiter: Warwickshire County Council

Environmental Health Officer

£27,741 to £33, 782
We have an opportunity in our Health and Safety Team for an Experienced Health and Safety Officer Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Senior Technician - Asset Management - Highways & Flood Risk

£23,541 to £29,577 per annum (Grade G)
We are currently looking to recruit to two exciting opportunities who will join us and play a role in improving West Berkshire’s highways. Newbury, Berkshire
Recruiter: West Berkshire Council

Street Works Co-ordinator

£21,153 - £23,791
Do you want to make a difference to how Street Works are managed within Lincolnshire? Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Principal Transport Planning Officer

£44,863 - £46,845. In addition, re-location expenses may also be paid.
This is an exciting opportunity to join the Strategic Transport Planning Team at Gloucestershire County Council (GCC). Gloucester, Gloucestershire
Recruiter: Gloucestershire County Council

Group Engineer - Highways Network Management

£40,876 - £45,859 Plus market rate supplement of £3,000, reviewed annually
We are looking for a Group Engineer who will support the recovery from the pandemic. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Group Engineer - Safety Design

£40,876 - £45,859 Plus market rate supplement of £3,000, reviewed annually
We are looking for an experienced engineer to join our Highways Safety Design team. Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Highways Asset Management Engineer

£30,451 - £32,234 per annum
The post holder will... Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Senior Traffic Engineer

£32,910 - £35,745 per annum
This is an exciting opportunity to join Telford & Wrekin Council’s Highway Network Management Team to... Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Traffic Signals Engineer

£25,991 - £35,745
An exciting opportunity has arisen for a Technician/Engineer to join the Traffic Signals Systems & Operations (TSSO) team as a Career Grade Engineer. Lincoln, Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Street Lighting Design Engineer

£18,812 - £35,745
This is an exciting opportunity for you to join Lincolnshire County Council's Street Lighting Team as a Street Lighting Design Engineer. Lincoln, Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Project Engineers

£36,922 per annum (Grade H-I)
West Berkshire Council are looking for innovative, enthusiastic and focused Project Engineers. Newbury, Berkshire
Recruiter: West Berkshire Council

Charge Hand (Highways)

£24,943 to £27,067 per annum
We are looking for motivated individuals who are willing to contribute to the team’s growth and success. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Principal Highways Drainage Engineer

£32,910 - £35,745 per annum
Do you want to take a leading role maintaining a large network of assets? Telford, Shropshire
Recruiter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Cleaner Streets and Waste Contract Manager - Communities

£48,809 - £49,794 per annum
Responsible for managing the street cleansing, household waste collections services and community recycling centres Bridgend (Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr)
Recruiter: Bridgend County Borough Council

Senior Engineer Flood & Drainage

£40,876 - £45,859
We make a difference to the environment we live in. Come and help us manage our blue infrastructure. Bracknell, Berkshire
Recruiter: Bracknell Forest Borough Council

Senior Engineer

£31,339 to £35,754 per annum
We are looking for enthusiastic and motivated individuals who are willing to contribute to the teams growth and success. York, North Yorkshire
Recruiter: City of York Council

Waste Collection Operative - Loaders / HGV Drivers (Hays Recruitment)

Competitive Salary
Hays are excited to be working in partnership with Chelmsford City Council who are always looking to expand their teams and are looking for... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Highways Presents

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video