Exclusive: Highways procurement survey - steps forward but still held back

10/07/2018

The latest Highways/FiTZ INDEX survey has revealed deep concerns within the sector about the nature of procurement, especially its ability to foster innovation, take on and share risk, bring in new entrants and support SMEs. However, while there is a feeling procurement itself is not evolving there are signs the sector itself is ready to take steps to drive change.

Less than one in five members of the roads sector (19.8%) feel that procurement satisfies its needs and only a third feel public sector strategies are evolving towards more satisfactory outcomes, the latest Highways/FiTZ INDEX survey has revealed.

image

The exclusive survey demonstrates key concerns and a deep ambivalence to how procurement works within the highways sector, particularly for the supply chain and SMEs.

The majority of respondents (54.3%) disagreed or strongly disagreed that ‘procurement in the highways sector is fair for non-Tier One suppliers and for new entrants’. No one strongly agreed with the statement. And 79% strongly agreed or agreed that ‘procurement has, intentionally or otherwise, actually driven more risk averse behaviours from suppliers over the last five years’. No respondent strongly disagreed.

image

There was ambivalence over whether public sector procurement strategies evolve from one contract period to the next, and are progressing towards more satisfactory shared sector outcomes. Few respondents had strong feelings one way or another, but 39.5% disagreed or strongly disagreed – an exact third (33.3%) strongly agreed or agreed.

The survey comes after the Institution of Civil Engineers (ICE) launched its latest attempt to shake-up procurement in the infrastructure sector under the Project 13 initiative, which calls for radical changes to roles and responsibilities under a more integrated ‘Enterprise Model’ (See Highways June 2018).

image

Senior figures in the sector, including Amey’s head of highways, James Haluch, and AECOM’s Europe sector leader for highways, Dave Beddell, have also lined up to call for change.

The survey asked: ‘Do you feel your organisation is willing to embrace a new model of service delivery – such as the Project 13’s Enterprise Model – as opposed to the traditional client contractor model?’

Encouragingly, close to half the respondents (45.7%) said yes to such a major change. However almost one in ten (9.9%) said no and 44.4% were unsure. The fact that so many remain unconvinced of the potential for change leaves questions for the whole sector to answer.

The simplest question of all, yet perhaps the most complex issue, was ‘who should be most responsible for driving innovation in procurement?’ Two thirds (66.7%) said the public sector and a third said the private sector. However more than 70% of respondents were from the private sector.

image

In total there were 81 respondents covering almost the full range of sector roles including central government client, regional city or local government client, Tier One contractors, supply chain partners and consultant designers and advisors.

How can we improve?

As part of the survey we asked respondents to suggest changes that need to be made to improve procurement in the sector. Common themes developed around the large cost, and lengthy time involved in the process and a lack of transparency preventing more genuine collaboration.

image

Respondents also suggested that action needed to be taken to help new entrants and SMEs compete for work and provide more innovation in the market.

A lack of skills and clarity over desired outcomes in the public sector was also raised a number of times. One respondent said: ‘Bring a regional delivery focus on the bigger goals for all to coalesce around and solve, to raise focus up and above just delivering the contract. Speaking as an SME, I’d like to see a move away from framework agreements that end up with a handful of Tier One suppliers each with enormous supply chains.’

Another respondent said the risk/reward model is imbalanced and change in the risk/reward profile ‘needs urgent action’.

‘If we want to truly work together for innovation and efficiency, we need to stop being so driven by competitiveness and ensure that margins are sustainable, which they are not currently.’

Another response suggested: ‘A shared mutual benefit to incentivise all within the supply chain and client organisations to actively seek continuous improvement for the delivery of efficiencies, leading to unit rate reductions and the elimination of waste. To eliminate the current business operating model of high turnover with low margins to one of high turnover and high margins based upon a culture of continually seeking perfection in a zero waste culture and a single integrated team approach.’

Other notable suggestions included: ‘Perhaps something following the Department of Transport’s [specialist technical advice for rail] STAR framework for rail, which encourages new entrants and companies of different sizes, could help.’

Another argued better data on cost would help: ‘Most of the clients and consultants only really have data on selling price. If we could all really understand cost and work to reduce that there would be more room for the industry to pay itself decent margins. As it is, this transparency is very difficult to achieve because of the fragmented nature of the supply chain with multiple subcontract and supply layers adding to the price.’

 

 

Also see

Latest Issue

latest magazine issue

Inside

  • The £2.5bn Surrey partnering contract
  • The politics of protest
  • Stoke's roadworks league
View the latest issue


Highways jobs

Shopmobility & Public Convenience Attendant

Grade 3 - Starting at £18,657 per annum, pro rata rising to £19,905
We are looking for an individual who works well in a small team to deliver an excellent level of service at our flagship Market Road Public Conveni... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Waste Collection Operative - HGV Driver/Loader

Grade 5 - Starting at £23,403 per annum, rising to £25,791
If you enjoy working outside and would like to make a positive contribution to the collection of both waste and recycling in the Borough, this coul... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Director of Climate Emergency & Behavioural Change

£95,000 to £109,000 per annum
At Waltham Forest we are developing an ambitious, transformative agenda to tackle the global Climate Emergency. Waltham Forest, London (Greater)
Recruiter: London Borough of Waltham Forest

Street Works and Permitting Manager

£44,863 - £51,817
Are you a qualified highways engineer who wants to make a difference to the efficient running of the highway network within Lincolnshire? Lincolnshire
Recruiter: Lincolnshire County Council

Warehouse Assistant/Driver

£20,903 - £24,491 per annum
An opportunity has arisen for the recruitment of a Warehouse Assistant / Driver. Sandwell, West Midlands
Recruiter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Highways Officer

£27,741 to £30,451
Are you someone who is looking to progress their career with one of the most highly regarded highway services in the country? Brompton, Northallerton
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Highways Officer

£27,741 to £30,451
Are you someone who is looking to progress their career with one of the most highly regarded highway services in the country? Boroughbridge, York
Recruiter: North Yorkshire County Council

Bus Support Officer

£24,086
We are looking for people to work as part of our exciting new bus team! Camden, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Camden London Borough Council

Environmental Health/Environmental Protection Officer - Noise

£41,607.00 - £44,598.00
This post attracts an essential car user allowance. The post holder is able to take part in the Council's flexible working scheme. Tower Hamlets, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Tower Hamlets London Borough Council

Greenspace & Environment Enforcement Officer

£20,092 - £24,491
You will work as part of a team undertaking environmental enforcement activities which focus on improving the street environment Huddersfield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Strategic Transport Modelling Manager

£47,695 - £55,226
You will provide leadership to the organisations program of transport model development Leeds, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: West Yorkshire Combined Authority

Engineer - Highway Planned Maintenance

£22,183 - £27,041
We are seeking to appoint an Officer with highway experience. We are delivering a Highway Investment programme across... Stockport, Greater Manchester
Recruiter: Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council

Cleaning Operative

Grade 2 - £17,715 per annum, pro rota.
Chelmsford City Council are seeking a self-motivated, experienced and customer-focused Cleaning Operative to join our cleaning team. You will provi... Chelmsford, Essex
Recruiter: Chelmsford City Council

Assistant Quantity Surveyor - Highways Contracts & Commissioning (multiple posts)

£27,741 - £29,577
In return, the Council offers a variety of benefits including Local Government Pension Scheme, flexible working and an opportunity to be... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Performance & Assurance Manager - Highways Contracts & Commissioning

£38,447 - £41,412
The post holder will provide professional contract performance management and compliance support to... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Construction Cost Manager - Highways Contracts & Commissioning

£43,597 - £46,875
With exciting new developments and high profile projects underway and in the pipeline for many years to come, working with... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Programme Manager - Project Delivery

£43,597 - £46,875
The role requires a Programme Manager who understands the range of... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Team Leader - Programme Management Officer

£49,268 - £53,170
The post holder will be a technically competent leader with excellent organisational and communication skills to... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Project Officer - Project Delivery (multiple roles)

£27,741 - £29,577
The role requires skills, knowledge and understanding of project management and facilitating stakeholder groups, being able to... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Senior Project Officer - Project Delivery (multiple posts)

£33,816 - £36,470
With exciting new developments and high profile projects underway and in the pipeline for many years to come, working with... Cambridgeshire
Recruiter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Highways Presents

Highways on Fridays

Register now!

Latest Video