National Highways refuses to disclose smart motorway SVD status

23/04/2024 | CHRIS AMES AND DOMINIC BROWNE

National Highways has refused to disclose how many of its failing smart motorway safety systems have nevertheless been cleared for permanent operation, increasing the risk for drivers on all lane running (ALR) routes.

When National Highways first planned the roll-out of radar-based stopped vehicle detection (SVD) for ALR smart motorways it set a clear testing process for each individual installation to pass before it could be officially declared 'business as usual'.

It now says it has 'determined that the system has improved sufficiently' at a national level to be passed into business as usual, despite the fact that individual schemes have failed to hit benchmarks.

The testing framework is important as it allows ALR schemes to operate at 70mph indefinitely – and a failure to pass the performance benchmarks has previously been cited as a relevant factor in a fatal crash.

In 2022 National Highways’ executive director for operations, Duncan Smith, told Highways that a fatal crash on the M4 – when the stopped vehicle detection (SVD) system had failed to alert operators to a stopped vehicle – had happened when ‘the scheme was still in operational acceptance’ and hadn’t yet ‘been handed into business as usual’.

Core requirements for SVD are:

  1. to detect 80% of stopped vehicle ‘events’
  2. for detection to take place within 20 seconds
  3. for the proportion of false detections to be lower than 15%.

If these requirements are not met, testing should continue 'with a cycle of root cause analysis, implementing improvements and re-testing' until they are.

In January 2023, the company told Highways that none of its SVD schemes had transitioned to business as usual ‘as they are not yet meeting all of the core performance requirements’.

Last year, following a software upgrade, National Highways retested all 21 schemes having changed its methodology to the point where it based its calculations on just 15% of stopped vehicle events.

Its monitor, the Office of Road and Rail (ORR), reported in December that the system was achieving an 89% detection rate nationally.

However, one region fell below the 80% benchmark and last week, Highways revealed that five of the 21 individual schemes had fallen below the detection benchmark. If you factor in the requirement to detect incidents within 20 seconds only around half make the grade. 

Following the ORR report, Highways asked National Highways how many individual schemes had passed into business as usual.

It did not answer the question directly but stated that ‘the treatment of alerts, automatic sign setting and our approach to faults is all in line with our normal ways of working’, suggesting that SVD systems that have not passed testing are being operated at 70mph – apparently indefinitely.

National Highways has said that the testing process has not changed. However, it appears to have moved from a scheme-by-scheme basis to a system basis.

A spokesperson told Highways: ‘We’ve determined that the system has improved sufficiently at national level to allow [handover to business as usual]. This has been the message from ORR also.’

The spokesperson argued that ‘individual tests are indicators at a moment in time’ and that ‘with the small sample sizes, the results would be different tomorrow’. National Highways insisted that the sample size for individual schemes is too small to make an informed decision on efficacy. 

A National Highways spokesperson added that testing will be repeated annually 'to continuously monitor and improve'.

The sample sizes of stopped vehicle events in the 24-hour window for ground truthing range from nine to 48 incidents for each of the 21 schemes, giving a total of 564. However, this is only after 3,286 events were thrown out under the new methodology.

While the ORR appears to agree on the point about the sample size, it told Highways: ‘[The] ORR has no role in approving how or when National Highways passes technology for business as usual.’ 

It declined to say how it decided it had no role in the process, despite its significant responsibility for overseeing safety on the strategic road network.

The ORR also pointed out that its December 2023 report had ‘called on the company to consider sample size and frequency of testing’.

Alan Hames, an experienced traffic engineer who gave evidence to a parliamentary inquiry into smart motorways, told Highways that in his opinion, the testing procedure must be fully complied with and signed off before any scheme can be declared as business as usual.

He described the process of declaring business as usual status by aggregating the results of schemes as ‘of great concern as it does not make clear and public this system is hiding failures, then allowing the signing off of a proportion of locations known to be under par’.

Recognising that the effectiveness of radar-based systems is site specific and subject to geographical and topographical features, he added: ‘All locations should only reach business as usual on an individual basis, site by site.’

Highways InProfile

latest magazine issue
Highways jobs

Project Lead - Bridges and Structures WMF3037e

£45,718 to £46,731
We are currently seeking to recruit a Project Lead to join our Bridges and Structures team Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Traffic Management Technician - WMF3040e

£27,711 - £28,624
Are you an organised and motivated individual who wants to make a difference to how our roads are managed? Cumbria / Various
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Traffic Management Officer - WMF2114e

£37,035 - £37,938
Are you an experienced and motivated professional looking to take the next step in your traffic management career? Cumbria / Various
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Senior Transport Planner

£47,532 - £50,574
Royal Greenwich is a borough synonymous with first class modern services Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recruiter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Technician - Highway Inspector

Grade 8 £28,797 - £30,708 per annum (Pay Award Pending)
Within the Highways Maintenance Team we are looking for an enthusiastic, customer focused and experienced person to join the Service Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Project Delivery Senior Team Leader

£74,480 - £85,964
Are you an experienced Chartered Civil Engineer (or equivalent professional qualification) Glasgow City
Recruiter: Transport Scotland

Assistant Traffic Management Technician - WMF2104e

£25,584 - £25,992
Westmorland and Furness Council is seeking an organised and enthusiastic individual to join our South Lakeland team Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Bulky Operative

£25,584.00 - £27,269.00, Grade 5, 37 hours, Permanent.
An opportunity exists in the Council’s Street Scene Services for a Bulky Operative Wakefield, West Yorkshire
Recruiter: Wakefield Council

Project Delivery Team Leader

£57,710 - £71,842
Are you an experienced Chartered Civil Engineer (or equivalent professional qualification). Glasgow City
Recruiter: Transport Scotland

Traffic Management Officer - WMF2102e

£37,035 - £37,938
This is a key role supporting the delivery a wide range of traffic and road safety schemes. Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Shared Service Manager (Waste) North Herts Council

£52000 - £61000 per annum
Shared Service Manager (Waste) North Herts CouncilNorth Herts CouncilPermanent, Full Time£52,866 - £61,866 per annum, plus car allowance (pay award pe England, Hertfordshire, Letchworth Garden City
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Street Scene Protection Officer - Braintree District Council

£30000 - £34000 per annum
Street Scene Protection Officer - Braintree District CouncilBraintree District CouncilPermanent, Full Time£30,313 to £34,612 per annumLocation
Recruiter: Essex County Council

Traffic Management Officer - WMF2102e

£37,035 - £37,938
This is a key role supporting the delivery a wide range of traffic and road safety schemes. Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Assistant Traffic Management Technician - WMF2104e

£25,584 - £25,992
This is a key support role, helping to deliver a wide range of traffic and road safety schemes across South Lakeland. Kendal, Cumbria
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

Flood Risk Engineering and Strategy Officer

£49,764 - £55,623
In line with our One Coventry Values, we want to ensure that our communities are represented across our workforce Coventry, West Midlands
Recruiter: Coventry City Council

Senior Integrated Transport Officer

£34,324 - £37,529
Are you an experienced transport planning professional ready to influence strategic policy and drive real change Matlock, Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Roadworker Trainee LGV Driver (3 Posts)

Grade 6 £25,183 - £25,638 per annum (Pay award pending)
We’re looking for Roadworker/trainee LGV drivers to be part of our team undertaking major highway, bridge and related construction and reconstruction Derbyshire
Recruiter: Derbyshire County Council

Engineer

£44,430 - £51,663
This post is within the Highways Design and Delivery Team. London (Greater)
Recruiter: Tower Hamlets London Borough Council

Civil Enforcement Officer - WMF3013e

£27,711 -£28,624
Are you seeking an active and challenging role, part of a friendly and welcoming team? Cumbria / Various
Recruiter: Westmorland and Furness Council

UGO Bus Driver

Up to £25081.00 per annum
UGO Bus DriverPermanent, Part TimeUp to £25,081 per annum (full time equivalent)Location
Recruiter: Essex County Council
SUBSCRIBE NOW

Latest Video

Subscribe to Highways today to ensure you keep your finger on the pulse of everything happening in the UK road network throughout the year.

SUBSCRIBE NOW